• Does everything have a start?


    The dictionary gives two definitions of eternal:

    - eternal inside time. This is presentism. Requires actual infinity to exist.
    - eternal outside time. This is eternalism. Does not require infinity.

    So I believe the 1st is impossible whereas the 2nd is possible.
    Devans99

    Interesting. And do you know any rational explanation on how could anything be "eternal outside time"?
  • Does everything have a start?


    space-time can exist eternally even though time has a startDevans99

    How would you define "eternally" in this context? In other words, what is your definition of "eternal" or "eternity"?
  • Does everything have a start?


    A start of time rules out presentist models of time; it does not rule out eternalist models.Devans99

    Please advance a rational argument to prove what you assert.
  • Does everything have a start?


    You wrote: "No matter what science comes up with, like the Big Bang, one can always ask the question, and what existed before that?"

    However, if we assume that time itself has a beginning, the question of what was before the beginning of time becomes irrational, hence invalid.