The popularity of Trump was down to his being a political outsider - ie not the Republican party. — Tim3003
Yes, votes for Trump are fundamentally a rejection of the status quo political class. The evidence for this is Bernie Sanders, who represents the same kind of rejection on the left. Two very different candidates with two very different policies, united by their ability to speak to a loss of faith in the status quo.
What's driving this at a most fundamental level is the
accelerating development of knowledge, which is driving social change at a pace faster than our ability to adapt. For every steel worker who lost their middle class union job to globalization and automation there are 20 people thinking it might be them next, and it probably will be. Perhaps the only candidate in this election to intelligently address the underlying driver of the uncertainty contagion was Andrew Yang.
The reach for extreme remedies by the broad public is going to get worse because few to none of our cultural elites, not politicians, scientists, academics or philosophers etc have the slightest clue how to effectively respond to the accelerating development of knowledge and the destabilizing social change it generates.
The heart of the problem is that the accelerating development of knowledge is challenging us to look at ever more fundamental issues at an ever faster pace. And we're just not ready.
And so a person with a rare talent for projecting confidence comes along and offers us simple solutions like Make America Great Again, and we don't know what else to do or who else to trust, so we give it a try.
His personal charisma - as witnessed by a successful TV career - is considerable, whatever we think of his politics he is great at communicating with the uneducated and fearful conservatives of rural USA. — Tim3003
It's more complicated than that. The "uneducated and fearful" rural folks you speak of have correctly identified that the status quo political class is corrupt, and more importantly, incapable of dealing with the challenges of the 21st century. They are united with the educated and urban folks who have come to the same correct conclusion. Bernie Sanders is even more radical than Trump because, unlike Trump, he sincerely believes in his prescriptions. Bernie Sanders would be a far bigger gamble than Trump, who has left the country largely unchanged.
Furthermore, while I'm ranting, the insistence of SO MANY liberals on insulting rural and working class Americans is an act of pure stupidity. Nothing that we liberals care about will ever be achievable and durable without bringing a great many of the red states folks on board. So long as insult based polarization persists then anything we might achieve will simply be reversed the next time the political pendulum swings.
We don't win until we make some kind of peace with all those red states you see spread across the heart of America.