The Philosophy Forum

  • Forum
  • Members
  • HELP

  • What caused the Big Bang, in your opinion?
    ↪an-salad
    My own belief is that the universe never actually started in the BB... as the song goes there's no beginning and there's no ending...
  • How can one know the ultimate truth about reality?
    ↪PeterJones
    So what is that: "The knowledge you are seeking lies beyond sensory data, trustworthy or not."?
  • How can one know the ultimate truth about reality?
    ↪PeterJones
    Beyond sensory data, are you alluding to 'faith' here?
  • How can one know the ultimate truth about reality?
    ↪Arcane Sandwich
    well you know my hallucinations might tell me something about reality... who knows. :-)
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zE7PKRjrid4

    BTW, I took both the red and blue pills... :-D
  • How can one know the ultimate truth about reality?
    ↪javi2541997
    Well, why not to dare to question my senses if I may hallucinate something etc then my senses can be fooled.
    If my senses can be fooled then how can I trust my senses?

    To tell you the truth I was diagnosed with schizophrenia some 22 years ago, I lost touch with reality; so it makes me wonder what is indeed real and what is not.
    I spend too much time in the computers anyways...

    Perhaps I should take a break and watch Venom... that Homological Algebra can be quite tiresome...
    :-D
  • A -> not-A
    ↪NotAristotle
    Don't know. There are all sorts of logics out there.
  • Does Tarski Undefinability apply to HOL ?
    The problem with higher than first order logic, is that they don't have a complete proof theory.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second-order_logic
    (under MetaLogical results).
  • A -> not-A
    ↪NotAristotle
    In the logic you are using can we use modus ponens as an inference rule?
  • Believing in nothing.
    ↪flannel jesus
    As Einstein once said "everything is relative". I believe in everything and in nothing. There was once a poster called grady from physicsforums who in his signature wrote:"why should I believe if I can just disbelieve".
    I don't know to what to believe anymore, so many faiths, and that's my truth. :-(
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHHvEksC7oc&ab_channel=NuclearBlastRecords

    But Einstein also said "God doesn't play dice", i.e he disbelieved Quantum Physics is the correct picture of reality. Are there any mainstream physicists nowadays who disbelieve Quantum Physics, I don't think there is such, but no one understands it (as the saying goes). Who was it quoted that he likes the "shut up, and calculate" interpretation?
    https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shut_up_and_calculate
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IgY-dpDKiJI&t=734s&ab_channel=JediMasterGeoff

    Sometimes, I do believe that I am God though.
    As Aristotle said:
    https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/aristotle_399587

    Yeah Long live the Misanthrope!
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFug3xQBKAk&ab_channel=NuclearBlastRecords
  • Believing in nothing.
    ↪flannel jesus
    That's it, I don't know what is a "sane person".
  • Believing in nothing.
    ↪flannel jesus
    Define to me "sane person".
  • Believing in nothing.
    ↪universeness
    I know. You gotta love Logic!
  • Believing in nothing.
    A classical song:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSbKNkPlrxk&ab_channel=fallenleaf25
  • What is real?
    ↪180 Proof
    The existence of God.
  • What is real?
    something can be real to me but not real to someone else.

    That's what I am getting at.
  • What is real?
    Reality is what you believe to be real, in short.
  • What is real?
    ↪Vera Mont
    Let's see if I can't depend on my senses to gather what is real then I left with my mind.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WM8bTdBs-cw&ab_channel=Metallica

    And I might hallucinate, but the hallucination is my reality.
  • Solipsism
    ↪Moliere
    You,I,me,him,her, everybody needs some recognition cause being all alone is quite a freitening thought to bear. But eventually all our are dear loved ones will perish and die... :-(
  • Solipsism
    And when I think about it, now I just might be talking to myself... :-D
  • Solipsism
    ↪Moliere
    When you think about it really. In philosophy there are only questions and no answers. As opposed to maths,physics,engineering and logic where there should be a definite answer to every question even if the problem is unanswerable, then answer is that it's unanswerable.
    So I think I contradicted my self here, and philosophy does have answers that we cannot answer those question really, that is the answer.
  • Solipsism
    ↪Moliere
    Quite hilarious, ain't it?!
  • Solipsism
    ↪Moliere
    Don't be so humble, you are a genius!
  • Solipsism
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OAVnOz7i-JA
  • Solipsism
    :-D
  • Solipsism
    ↪Moliere
    You didn't but I did.
    so yes you did.
  • Statements are true?
    If you want to write it in Doxastic Logic's notation then it's: from Bp being true you can entail that p is true.
  • Statements are true?
    ↪Alkis Piskas
    The Socrates theme was a reply to Banno's DisneyLand YT film.

    Anyways, the Liar paradox can also be regarded as both true and false.
    As long as you or I or him believe something to be true, then it's true.
  • Statements are true?
    ↪Alkis Piskas
    It doesn't matter if it's true for others, as long as you or I or him believe it to be true.
    Besides of course tautologies and contradictions, and statements like "I am a Liar" which are by definition always true or always false.

    As for Socrates I am not even sure he ever existed, perhaps he is/was a fictional character...'
    What's the difference between fiction and reality in that case? it depends on what do you believe of course...
  • Statements are true?
    Something is true, if you believe it to be true.

    Obviously Av~A is true and A&~A is false. Other statments are contingents, as in are not a tautology nor contradictions.
    That's all there's to it really... :-)
  • Aristotelian logic: why do “first principles” not need to be proven?
    ↪javi2541997

    Well, you need ro assume something, don't you?

    Unless you want to assume the empty assumption of not assuming anything... :-)
    In which case you cannot argue anything.
  • Can you prove solipsism true?
    In what type of Logic do you want your proof to be served to you?
  • What does "real" mean?
    ↪frank
    Like our conversation.

    Reality is habitual hallucination, whatever that means... :-)
  • What does "real" mean?
    ↪frank
    Does Jack think the bartender is real or not?
    You are contradicting yourself.
  • What does "real" mean?
    ↪frank
    So he's not real, because he doesn't believe the bartender is real.
  • What does "real" mean?
    ↪frank
    How do you know?
  • What does "real" mean?
    ↪frank
    Then he's real.
  • What does "real" mean?
    ↪Agent Smith
    Real is what you believe to be real.
  • Reflection schema
    Another book which should be on every logician shelfs is Logic of provability by George Boolos. I started reading it years ago, I believe this should be covered there not sure 100 percent because I never finished reading this book. I read it back in my undergraute years as a student of maths and physics combined.
  • Reflection schema
    I am not sure this is addressed in those books. But are you acquainted with peter smith's book and Smullyan's books?
  • If a first cause is logically necessary, what does that entail for the universe's origins?
    First cause is not a logical necessity.
    Existence is either way paradoxical.
    You can find a system where it's necessary and a system where it's not necessary.

    We don't know what is the truth, maybe after death we'll know, or we might not know either, this life may all be a dream within a dream ad infinitum, waking up from one dream to the next...
Home » A Realist
More Comments

A Realist

Start FollowingSend a Message
  • About
  • Comments
  • Discussions
  • Uploads
  • Other sites we like
  • Social media
  • Terms of Service
  • Sign In
  • Created with PlushForums
  • © 2025 The Philosophy Forum