JerseyFlight
Ciceronianus
JerseyFlight
Well, I haven't thought about God for some time, and there was apparently nothing He could do about it. — Ciceronianus the White
Pantagruel
the axiom of all philosophy, the being of thought — JerseyFlight
Deleted User
Deleted User
JerseyFlight
You believe God is only a product of thought and has no independent existence. — Coben
we just have an assumption/assertion, not an argument. — Coben
Pantagruel
↪Pantagruel it is very unlkely that thought is your central motivation. It is more likely that it is emotions. (I am not insulting or ad homing you, this is true for all of us. Motivations and desires set us in motion. ) — Coben
jkg20
JerseyFlight
Perhaps for Hegel God and thought, although intially in apparent contradiction, become finally synthesised in Spirit? — jkg20
MAYAEL
Outlander
BitconnectCarlos
Sir2u
The real question is why does one need God when one has thought? — JerseyFlight
jkg20
Well, that seems a little too strident. English speaking idealist interpreters of Hegel such as McTaggart and Stace, different kinds of idealist admittedly, but no idiots either of them, find in Hegel's dialetic the "Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis" model. It's not the be all and end all of his philosophy of course and those interpreters might be wrong, but it seems too involved an exegitical issue to just discard it out of hand as you do.VERY IMPORTANT: Thesis, Antithesis and Synthesis has nothing to do with Hegel's position.
Pfhorrest
In this moment I am euphoric, not because of any phony God's blessing but because I am enlightened my own intelligence. — BitconnectCarlos
JerseyFlight
English speaking idealist interpreters of Hegel such as McTaggart and Stace, different kinds of idealist admittedly, but no idiots either of them, find in Hegel's dialetic the "Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis" model. — jkg20
JerseyFlight
I think you're taking this a bit too far - it's like a cat with fangs and claws thinking that fangs are claws are far superior than everything else and cats know better. — TheMadFool
BitconnectCarlos
Judaka
JerseyFlight
I think that thought has the power to dictate any narrative — Judaka
Judaka
this too and the opposite. Wouldn't you agree?It has the capacity to transcend narratives, even to correct itself. — JerseyFlight
JerseyFlight
Judaka
JerseyFlight
That thought does not have the capacity to transcend narratives — Judaka
jkg20
EnPassant
The Deity is a formation of thought, it is not a concrete substance. — JerseyFlight
Frank Apisa
In the first instance, the very formation of the Phantom-Deity is itself the outcome of a thinking process, without this process there is no Phantom. — JerseyFlight
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.