Most atheists want God not to exist as to be able to tell to those who believe "I told you! I was right!". Maybe they are secretly envy of people who believe. Cause those (even if they are wrong. And imo they are) at least they have answered to their existential questions. Atheists are condemned to "suffer" from the lust of knowledge

Feelings projections. Part of them that humans can have awareness at least

So what is life for you then since you separate breath from it?

It seems to me that by Spirit you consider life then. Since we think alive everything that breaths. Existance of life is Spirit for you then

And if Spirit is breath? What about plants then? Since they breath too we can say that they also have Spirit?

It might be true also indeed

So give me your short definition for soul also

So you think that this principle exists like a rule in universe in general and it is something that humans can't interfere with? Or humans mind play its role too in the way of how all these stuff go united? For you Spirit is like a principle that happens to all humans in a same way? Or each human has its own unique way of how all these things gets combined together?

So as I asked Banno. You believe Spirit is only in humans or all animals has Spirit too?

I also see Spirit as the process behind breath as you mentioned. For me breath is just the biological effect that is required for Spirit's existance

Nice definition. So that illumination in your opinion it happens in a something energetic level or it's pure mind's process?

So anything that breathes has Spirit? It's not only human's "privillege"?

So as you said the emotive aspect of an experience you have like the song you mentioned. But How it interacts with your emotions. The process that the song through your mind "creates" that emotionally energy around you isn't a indication of soul existence? Or you believe that even the way it interacts to you emotions is a pure job of mind? Well for me the shortest definition for soul is :That Soul is the universal energy inside human. And that kind of energy has some to do with the soul system of human. In a way it is the Aura that covers the person. That energy that interacts with human feelings in unconscious way. But as you said it might be totally wrong.. Lol

When you read the book just write what is the idea you got for what spirit is If you want of course. The reason I want the simplest answer is cause exactly since it is such a complex issue with so many aspects still I havent found a definition that is clear without huge analysis. Cause even in great thinkers and philosophers books they might use Spirit many times and in many cases they use to describe different things. Using and thinking of Spirt like a geeeeneral term that includes everything isn't enough for me. Of course it's a huge matter. But what is the meaning you give to it?You can't use terms like spirit and soul referring to different issues without giving a definition of what exactly is that you believe spirit is. And by you I don't mean you of course I mean anyone who use these terms.

Well do you actually believe in soul existence? And if yes is there a way that mind and soul communicate? By the way give me your definition of soul also if you believe in it. I know I bombed you with question but you asked for it man. Sorry. Hahaha

It is mind blowing for me too. Maybe the fun after will be that human being ensured that there is nothing after death could learn new ways to discover happiness and how should persuade it. But maybe it's the opposite a total chaos in human physicism. I don't know either. But indeed I agree that quantum actually indicates that everything energy. And I have a sense that this universal energy that connect everything might be connected in human soul and all the things we have inside us and we can't describe it with words or see it but we are still sure there are there! Anyway It might be all wrong it's just what I sense

Ok thanks

Of course not. That's a total human egoist perception. Something to making think that his existence actually matters and superior others form of life. The antidote to death for human. Imagine you are an alien looking above why the fuck you would think that people this form of life in Earth is something special or its lives worths more than coakroaches for example. In all that chaos that is going on in Universe sorry but I wouldn't give a fuck about people if I were to alien's position.

Mind stuff you mean like it's an mind illusion and Spirit doesn't exist? Or like you call all minds functions Spirit?

The only logical solution for a human is to persuade his happiness. That's totally individual process. Working with yourself is the essence for me in individualism. But it's difficult for people to understand what happiness means and so on what individualism means. Plus its a tough soul fighting process. A battle that not many can stand. The fight with yourself is the toughest one. So that's why though I believe that indeed is the only solution I have still doubts if it's actually possible to happen. Well thats my view at least

In my opinion there is a "line" in everything and that line connects everything in universe. If people ever discover the Reason for everything. To answer to the Why question! Why everything happens like that. The Way it works. If people do ever achieve that I believe it will connect-answer to everything! It will connect all siences! It will be the line that connects all dots.so yes it will answer all philosophical questions too. If not then th questions will remain forever till science help

There is no problem at all. It's the only real functional solution. The problem is that people can't understand the function of individualism!! As most things they confuse the real understanding of what it should be. They just connect it like most things with Matter! Right use of individualism is the only realistic way of changing things for better terms of happiness to human societies

Tramsofrm people's mindset to Logic!! With its actions to push people think logically and make them understand that this is a total selfish thing to do for their own profit at the end! To fight hyprocrisis

Mind stuff you mean like it's an mind illusion and Spirit doesn't exist? Or like you call all minds functions Spirit?