So, on what basis do you reject it? — Bartricks
if it’s a contrapositive doesn’t it mean that thinking one is identical with thinking the other? He just wrote it in a weird way? — khaled
I deliberately ignored that because it should be blindingly obvious — S
Did you not read the remarks delivered by the judge in Choudary’s sentencing? — S
The minority want to belong to the majority — TheMadFool
Isn’t that just the contrapositive though? — khaled
The former consider the latter unnatural/abnormal. — TheMadFool
What words would you use to answer the question "what is pain like?" — Isaac
Don't you think the biggest problems humanity has faced, is facing and will face is predicated on distinction or difference? — TheMadFool
Yes, and "what it's like" there is doing the job of "similar but not necessarily identical" — Isaac
1. If I am morally responsible, then I have free will — Bartricks
I'm claiming that anyone with half a brain can work out the implications of what the Judge was saying, — S
Why is my one true? Because you can't argue for anything - anything at all - without presupposing its truth. — Bartricks
Nothing. — Bartricks
you can't argue for anything without presupposing its truth. — Bartricks
I am not guilty of any wishful thinking - it is you who is guilty of that, — Bartricks
I have presented three arguments — Bartricks
I am told repeatedly that my mind is my brain, but I see no evidence that this is the case. — Bartricks
Did you know that Jerry Garcia had four children? I'll bet you did. — T Clark