The Harper's Letter was dumb as hell; a circle-jerk for the signatories, all of whom have immense platforms and each of whom can directly reach an audience that all of us combined are unlikely to ever experience. The letter was so pitiful that it couldn't even provide direct, unambiguous examples of people who have been "canceled" and the whole term, (which is extremely goofy, by the way) is primarily a concern for people of a certain class or occupation or politico-ideological beliefs that want to distract away from actual material concerns that a majority of people face. What's also exceptional to me, is that a number of signatories are prominent political scientists who are unable to grasp the fact that "cancel culture" is a fundamental component of liberal democracy, i.e., the ability to freely associate with a group of other individuals with a common identity (ideological, ethnic, class, etc.) and to defend/protect that collective identity,
which will always be in tension with the freedom of speech insofar as the latter does or potentially harms the former, as is the case with say transrights (which signatories Jesse Singal and JK Rowling have done), or Black Americans (Haidt et. al. has defended race science), or Palestinians (Bari Weiss, who in fact become famous by trying to "cancel" i.e. fire a pro-Palestinian professor at Columbia). What the signers decry as a "force of illiberalism" is in actuality an element of liberalism, Freedom of Association, expressing itself.
I think that the letter is appropriate to be fully quoted:
Editors are fired for running controversial pieces — ssu
NYT sacking of their opinion editor because of complaints from readers — Benkei
Even more to the point than losing subscribers and caving to "mOb mEnTaLlIty" James Bennet, the Editorial Page Editor, was fired because
he didn't do his job. He said he "did not read the essay before it was published" and an internal review found that the publication was rushed and contained multiple false statements. This has happened multiple times under Bennet (
here is my favorite one). This was simply the straw the broke the camel's back. What the letter is expressing is an outright lie. Being fired because you suck at your job isn't an example of "cancel culture".
But do you know what is an example of "cancel culture"? An Amazon worker who was
fired for leading a protest due to the company's poor COVID response (and at-will employment in general), but I didn't see that example spelled out in the letter. In fact that right there is a more concrete example than anything offered by the letter.