Any Platonists?
i don't agree with everything they're saying. I agree that truth and objectivity are possible, but that doesn't mean that they, or I have attained it. Particularly the part about empathy favoring the cute, and not the ugly, and we can't have that. Are they then beyond that, and really don't trouble themselves with such human concerns, their significant others could look, and smell like a rotting corpse for all they care? They certainly have not transcended their emotions, and animalistic inclinations. Life is fundamentally different for Frankenstein than it is for a rock star. Just not killing them, perhaps telling them how beautiful they are out of pity will never change that. Their experiences of the world, and society will be fundamentally different. Monsters are made, by being treated as such. You can't understand another's position without walking in their shoes and all that. I'm deeply suspicious of anyone that imagines a class of people that are cruel and foolish, and themselves enlightened and good. That it was solely reason that was responsible for the changes over time is clearly not true. It's way more complex than that, rather than the ignorant masses running around being stupid and evil until supermen showed up to save them, most people, just as today were just living their lives, and sometimes killing people by accident because they were drunk, or out of passion. The people are utilized as pieces with deception coercion, or necessity. Either some political, religious, or hatemongering ideology, or because they were starving or in the midst of a disaster.
I do definitely believe in truth, and goodness, but I think that is damn hard to attain. I think that religions are the greatest sources of them. Thinking that they were ignorant plebs, and us brilliant moderns until the even more brilliant future people come along pays our ancestors a great disservice. It wasn't just reason itself, but the emotional maturity that is capable through the refinement, and transformations of our natures through the virtues espoused in all great religions.
Reason, truth, is universal in my view, not us, and not ours. We are those emotions, and through reason, can be transformed, but we have to listen.