Comments

  • Get Creative!
    AfVD4g4.jpg

    Photography... the artistic cheat, more consumptive, more about taking than making. An in-game picture of Gorilla Games Horizon: Zero Dawn virtual world above. A news outlet has been tricked into showing in-game photography as if it was mundane photograph. What's the difference if you can't tell the difference at first glance?

    tKZR3VD.jpg

    Guingamp, France 2011, River Walk. There is something about crawling ivy that is aesthetically satisfying, even though its a noxious grower. Kudzu... where are you?
  • What's your favorite Thought Experiment?
    The universe as a library of all possible books.

    The number of books about god must be atheist's sexual exploits with Pamela Anderson could not fit in our universe.
  • Authority and freedom
    What about the authority of the original post? Does a great sense of humility and openness underlay this inquiry into freedom with respect to the often clueless/useless experiences of others.

    Or can we reject it all, wholesale, because we ought to reject all authority. Upon what authority?

    Is there no contradiction rejecting all sources of authority, whether inward and outer? What guides us then?
  • Depression and Individualism
    There is possibly a very long list of the situations/factors/conditions which give rise to depression.

    Society is quite depressing from my point of view. Despite technological marvels everyone is continually being squeezed to propagate the cycle of economic growth. It's a kind of unsustainable ponzi scheme. We're told we need to be successful but at the same time that very drive for energy accumulation, enforced by our societal standard/status competition, is eroding global resources/stability.

    There is no job that can justify its gratuitous resource waste and yet folks cannot be allowed the right of the security to be housed, to sleep in a bed, clean themselves, et cetera.

    Life is insane. Why wouldn't depression be common?
  • Pleasure: recapturing the experience of yesterday
    If a Bodhi meets you in the wilds of Alaska become taller by picking up a log. Talk the Bodhi away with a loud confident voice. You could say: "shoo Bodhi, shoo". The typical advice is never to run from a Bodhi quickly, causing a stir. Casually disappear yourself from a Bodhi's presence, with a slow and cautious grace.
  • A philosopher's insulting compliment


    Great articles, excerpts and quotes. I especially like Hume quotes and one would wonder if any comparable expression of relief by social activity or from nature for mental disturbance was given by Nietzsche. I'm not sure serenity, contentment or happiness is at all compatible with whatever Nietzsche was advocating with such phrases as "Will to Power" and "The Overman."

    It would've never occurred to me to call contemporary statue tippers iconoclasts but it fits with the original spirit of the term quite well.

    Dying for one's beliefs as a choice, as is the case with the dramatic trial of Socrates, is interesting. The extremity of such an act in the face of death might be absurd/irrational/mad to many. If one could imagine an alternative history where Socrates gave up his work (the public practice of Elenchus) to remain alive, would he remain the so called "father of Western philosophy". It's kind of a great mythic/legendary opening to the movement of Western philosophy. But he was kind of old, so maybe there wasn't much at stake. Maybe he was tired of feeling his bones rubbing together.

    There is a point beyond which philosophy, if it is not to lose face, must turn into something else: performance. It has to pass a test in a foreign land, a territory that’s not its own. For the ultimate testing of our philosophy takes place not in the sphere of strictly rational procedures (writing, teaching, lecturing), but elsewhere: in the fierce confrontation with death of the animal that we are. — Costica Bradatan, NYT Opinionator: Philosophy as the Art of Dying

    Philosophy as an Art of Dying by Costica Bradatan
  • The River


    Good question, if posed innocently?! Who can discern your sincerity! You must sit quietly and observe your breath, the bellows rhythm of your respiration, as the flow of the universe. Know that you are one with the dancing bear.
  • The River
    [img]http://QYuW9LY.jpg

    An innocent mind must be properly conditioned to listen in order to perform for the benefit of other innocent minds.
  • A philosopher's insulting compliment
    Yet such a view directly contradicts the fact that Eros—being a god—can-not be the cause of anything bad; hence, Socrates must now recant his earlier disparagement of μανία [ manía ] and instead extol the virtues of madness. — Daniel Werner: Plato on Madness and Philosophy

    This is the kind of fact one must profess as a matter of convention, less you risk getting in trouble like Socrates did. How does one square this in the face of the mythical shenanigans of the gods who appear to be just powerful, unfathomable and mad versions of humans, susceptible to same instinctual frailties/ecstasies, like becoming jealous, seeking revenge, while using mortals as their means. If the gods had a hand in the accidental tragedies of mortals why hold the view that Eros (the madness of love) cannot be the cause of anything bad?

    First rule of scary as shit gods... don't gainsay them for fear of reprisal. They might shoot you with a love arrow while at the same time deny you the object of your love. Talk about evil.

    I am not sure about having original hypotheses or even if there was great future 'pay-off'.Amity

    Iconoclasts! The movers and the shakers, any of those, can be condemned by the current era conservatives to uphold the status quo as a matter of faith or power. If the wench doesn't drown, she's a witch, and therefore must be burned at the stake.
  • The River
    Does one listen if they are caught in the movements of acceptance and rejection? Is one listening if the new is being filtered through the old? Surely not.skyblack

    How can one understand what is being said without comparing it to the known, then to estimate it's potential value for acceptance or rejection on the basis of what is discovered by reason or known from memory to be good or bad?

    If Herman Hesse's passage was read aloud or written in original German (if he wrote it in German) to us non German speakers, we could not begin to listen (as some would have us listen) until we learned German. What is the exercise of language and learning but an evaluation of the new through the old?

    Do we require language (connected to the network memory of our past and its associations) to listen?
  • A philosopher's insulting compliment
    Socrates gadflying in public, totally cray cray.praxis

    The internal voice (the Daimonion) that told Socrates no whenever he was about to do something wrong sounds far weirder than his method, which was probably more annoying than crazy. But maybe it's just a creative take on what we call the conscience (though one doesn't audibly hear it). Greek society then, as much as society now, was all kinds of cray cray, given that everybody was running scared about speaking against the gods and slaves and pederasty were a okay.

    When in Athens, circa 399 BCE... go watch the chariot races, after watching Soc drink Hemlock.
  • A philosopher's insulting compliment
    Calling someone insane/crazy is sometimes a casual but still ambiguous compliment when the implied context is shared between two parties.

    Example: Alex Honnold is insane/crazy for free climbing El Capitan. This could both convey a sense of awe and envy in some people given the high probability of death if a mistake is made. Death defying feats require courage and skill, things which are generally commendable. A high risk move with incredible pay off, if successful, might be complimented with "crazy" by the average person who would never take such a risk.

    Example: Elon Musk's investment in sending humans to Mars is insane/crazy. Maybe commendable, as an achievement, like climbing El Capitan, but also incredibly stupid/wasteful from the point of view of intractable problems at home. Are there good reasons for sending humans to Mars? How would sending them to the moon be any different?

    I'd like an example of a crazy/insane philosopher. The heresiarchs of the old days, those who questioned institutional reality (Christian cosmogony) with original hypotheses were possibly insane/corrupt by the standards of the time, but there was great pay off for future generations. Newton was into magic and alchemy.

    Emil Cioran seems crazy, insofar a pessimism might arise from an illness (the body inflammed) or from tragedy. How could a serious pessimist like that exist and ought you really call him a philosopher rather than a poet. Or is it a kind of poets play/humor that is detached from his character, an artistic salve/work for the condition he was in.
  • Rings And Things Hidden In Plain Sight
    Well, it simply means that there's something out there, perhaps a quality, I'm not sure what, that's universal [present everywhere and everytime]TheMadFool

    There is the popular notion that other animals can detect an oncoming natural disaster before it is apparent to us, whether due to air pressure changes, rising water tables, et cetera. Not sure how well studied the phenomena is, if at all, but maybe that means we have the capacity to sense the same thing with our bare senses if we could tune out competing stimuli. Can humans detect air pressure changes? Seems the theory stands that some kinds of desensitization you describe helps to free up the ability to pay attention to other/new stimuli. It's about reducing cognitive load, an adaptation to keep us on our feet, ready for what is coming next.

    There is possibly a universal stimuli, being everywhere in the universe potentially sensible, the cosmic background radiation. But that is just kind of like the stuff angry god must be atheist is talking about, stuff that is potentially sensible depending on the nature of the apparatus and focus of the sensor.

    Edit: There is also metaphorical woo in the Advaita Vendanta tradition about the universal sound of God, related to the syllables AUM. Maybe it is just white noise (joke).
  • Polosophy
    Allow me to walk quietly in your shadowArguingWAristotleTiff

    Just running my mouth, shooting from the hip, inane, bolshy and benign shots. :pray:
  • Polosophy
    Dang! Do you give lessons?ArguingWAristotleTiff

    Nature gives the basic lessons. Trump would give you lessons but you'll probably have to pay the entry fee to Mara Lago and then some.

    The advertising funded media corporations and freelancers are the one's to give more sophisticated lessons, or the entities of the attention economy who have more insight about who we are then we do and who have a line into our psyches via our electronic pocket parasites.
  • God Debris
    It would explain why we feel so alone, so abandoned perhaps?CountVictorClimacusIII

    It's the new expansive view of the cosmos that had displaced us as the center of the universe that might explain some of this anxiety. The distances against the limit of the speed of light is kind of depressing. The vastness of space, the quantity of worlds out there and being stuck by gravity to a single orb in an uncrossable ocean. Further that these distances are growing.

    No one is texting us from across the expanse. Where is the universe's social media feed?

    I like the notion that humans left an embodied world (God) as they increasingly developed the memory mediated self. Maybe animals still live in the embodied world, where the dissection of the self and the world has not happened. The dawn of consciousness is a kind of curse but since we're already here, this is the party we have to attend. Might as well build a god (a mummy daddy) to replace the one lost.
  • Illusion of intelligence
    Funny thing is that superorganisms by historical example are always smarter than the component organisms.god must be atheist

    There is no way you can make this distinction. Smarter compared to what?
  • Illusion of intelligence
    And at the collective level, a step scale upwards... we might have the intelligence of slime mold or a dinosaur. It might take a small comment from a political nut job to wipe us out. We're all the embedded cells of a non-human superorganism.
  • Polosophy
    The true way is not to fight at all but to camouflage oneself, infiltrate the corpus, lay eggs and flee.
  • An Innocent Mind


    But your response is not driven by an emotional reaction? Not like an innocent bear. You're keep going on and on about how everyone has a corrupted mind... it stands to reason you're not excluded.

    Then you also project an assumption (not conditioned by corrupting knowledge) about what it is like to be a bear.

    No need to reply. But your poetry is kind of interesting, though dour, uncharitable, melancholy and nihilistic. The corruption has moved into my bowels. I must seek a toilet.
  • An Innocent Mind
    (wrong example. not only the wrong end of the stick, but it's the wrong stick)skyblack

    Apparently not, since we now know that a bear isn't corrupted by conditioned knowledge.

    a mind that is common to all humanity.skyblack

    But are you included or excluded as one who has a corrupted mind? I would be surprised if you alone could make that designation.
  • An Innocent Mind
    Well, I can vouch for what it looks like in the corrupt cloud of unknowing. It would be better if we (the corrupt) didn't fear the unknown so much, didn't project a version of the world that isn't true but helps us along anyway.

    It looks like everyone is playing a kind of patty cake, from the ants growing leaf mold to the golfers of the PGA hitting little balls across picturesque landscapes, to the anonymous and abstruse dialogues of this philosophy forum. Forms arising and falling away, transacting agents with there great and little dramas. Does it really matter what happens, as if there was any real control beyond the little self's daily decisions.

    If a bear eating salmon in a river is an example of a kind of mind corruption (conditioned knowledge) all I can do is shrug my shoulders. I would much rather be like a bear salmon fishing, with no relationship to a past or future self that engages a ceaseless anxiety, supposing that is the case. There is just life in motion, pain and pleasure which comes and goes, no concept of death or something to die.
  • An Innocent Mind
    The OP could jettison "corrupt" and "innocent" for different qualifying terms, like virtuous versus virtueless, skillful versus unskillful, logical versus non-logical, et cetera. Not much to be gained by giant black and white categories reminiscent of the church or court of law.
  • What are you listening to right now?
    Lord Huron has dropped a new album



    I swore that I'd become a better man for you and I tried
    Tried to change my ways and walk the line you follow
    I bore a flame that burned a thousand suns for you but it died
    Told you I could never love somebody else but I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    I told you I'd be coming back again for you but I'm not
    Going way out where the world will never find me
    I made a claim that I would dance until we're bones with my bride
    Told you I would never leave you all alone but I lied
    I read your letter in the morning by the lake and I cried
    They were tears of joy, my chains are finally broken
    I made a vow to stand beside you 'til the day that I die
    Told you I could never live without your love but I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    Mmm, I lied
    Mmm, I lied
  • An Innocent Mind
    Any lack of clarity is in the recipient's corrupted mind.skyblack

    I suppose that goes both ways though. You can't really be the objective judge of your own mind. The esteem you grant yourself is otherworldly if so.
  • An Innocent Mind
    Hope all this clarifies.skyblack

    Yes, you're much clearer but your value judgement using the strange words "corrupt" or "innocent" don't really mean anything because according to your language all minds are corrupt and innocent.
    You haven't adequately fleshed out the difference between these two types of mind.
  • Is life a "gift?"
    Can life really be a gift?TiredThinker

    At the risk of mixing metaphors, the glass of life is half full if we recognize it as a gift. Supposedly there are psychological benefits to exercising gratitude. There have been claims that the oceanic feeling that some are seeking as an antidote to unsatisfactoriness has neurological commonalities with "gratitude" and is drawn into dominance when the other brain regions (like the default mode network) are silenced.

    A life can also be full of gift giving and gift receiving. Maybe the cup fills up the more you give and are grateful for.

    Now about that gift you wanted to get me...
  • An Innocent Mind


    Sorry, you strike me as overly critical and what you are attempting to describe is unclear and seemingly in part contradictory.

    Implicit knowledge cannot help leave a mark on the mind as it develops. There are dysfunctional minds, unbalanced minds, depressed minds et cetera but a corrupt mind sounds like a self-interested immoral mind (like a sociopath) that exploits knowledge for power at the expense of the well being of others. Corruption is a judgement made from an a particular point of view, relative to a set of values. It would help to ground your generalities through real life particulars, or imagined characters.

    Or maybe on par with your abstraction, a corrupt mind is related to the maladaptive constraint of ego boundary, as is with depressed minds, where one cannot move forward constructively due to the emotively charged content of the past. One cannot step out of the bounds of the known and is thus limited by a fear mediated projection of the world (seeing through shit tinted spectacles).

    You can ignore me if you like, if it is good to avoid depressed (perhaps corrupt) minds.
  • An Innocent Mind
    The living space of some depressed and anxious minds are less than modest.

    Whether hung upside down naked on a steeple, or cleaving, white-knuckled, ropeless, to a shear cliff, or lost, neck high, down a well. It is no time or the right time to cur(s)e oneself. It would be so easy to leap if one weren't bound, less easy to grow too cold.

    We might venture that no animal is as cur(s)ed quite like us. The censorious mind, deranged driver of ego and the executive mind, augur of all pasts and futures, arbiter of motion, has given us the task of digging a grave or a foundation for what is to come.

    Go easy, censor. Live and let live.
  • What is your perspective on the word: Reflection of self?
    If you go to work without a face it is probably because you failed to consult the self in the looking glass.
  • What is your perspective on the word: Reflection of self?
    The reflection (dialogic analysis) of the self sounds like a metaphysical nightmare only a coterie of intrepid philosophers would care to plumb the depth of.

    Who dares enter the looking glass by metaphysical means when it is better to play cards and drink coffee.

    Inevitably a Buddhist will appear and say words like "Anatman" and "Shunyata" and then you'll have to run for the hills.
  • If you had the answer to world peace.
    There are all manner of disturbing sci-fi premises compatible with a peaceful world but I suppose peaceful entails a world of flourishing and healthy populace (otherwise why peace?).

    Maybe something like Westworld's Rehoboam, the grand central AI coordinator of all human affairs.
    Even if such a system were in some sense ideal, minimizing suffering or maximizing well being, there would still be something deeply disturbing about it.

    But maybe it would be less disturbing than current affairs. If we were denied knowledge of what the system actually is and lead to believe a lie for our own good, that would mean in some possible utopias, ignorance is bliss.
  • My favorite metaphors
    Maybe another downer bit lacking the contextualizing net of Borges work.

    ”This City is so horrible that its mere existence and perdurance, though in the midst of a secret desert, contaminates the past and the future and in some way even jeopardizes the stars. As long as it lasts, no one in the world can be strong or happy. I do not want to describe it; a chaos of heterogeneous words, the body of a tiger or a bull in which teeth, organs and heads monstrously pullulate in mutual conjunction and hatred can (perhaps) be approximate images.” — Narrator, The Immortal by Jorge Luis Borges

    This quote stood out to me palpably.

    The narrator is describing a city immortals have built and abandoned, possibly through excessive cycles of time. It is as disorienting as any of Borges metaphorical precursors/parallels like the Library of Babel or the Book of Sand or the memory of Funes, the Zahir, the Aleph, et cetera. These associative elements/themes/motifs echo and mirror the total work metaphorically/fractally.

    _____________________

    Net of Indra

    Far away in the heavenly abode of the great god Indra, there is a wonderful net which has been hung by some cunning artificer in such a manner that it stretches out infinitely in all directions. In accordance with the extravagant tastes of deities, the artificer has hung a single glittering jewel in each "eye" of the net, and since the net itself is infinite in dimension, the jewels are infinite in number. There hang the jewels, glittering "like" stars in the first magnitude, a wonderful sight to behold. If we now arbitrarily select one of these jewels for inspection and look closely at it, we will discover that in its polished surface there are reflected all the other jewels in the net, infinite in number. Not only that, but each of the jewels reflected in this one jewel is also reflecting all the other jewels, so that there is an infinite reflecting process occurring. — Francis H. Cook
  • Inspirational quotes!
    "At least you aren't the animal who checks his pocket parasite when standing in a checkout line."

    InspiroBot 2.0 (Flesh Version)
  • Sight or Sound?
    Hearing is less important from a standpoint of being able to function independently in the world.

    I'll keep my sight. Without hearing I'd be able to sleep in really noisy places. Would open up new opportunities to be at ease in otherwise unbearably noisy places. Restaurants would be serene.
  • What was the last truly great Final Fantasy game?
    You guys didn't fight Zeromus on the moon? It was epic.

    FF II (JPN 4)
    FF III (JPN 6)
    FF VII

    These were memorable but probably has more to do with when I played them. Don't like the aesthetic turn FF developed with later games. Nabuo Uematsu really did an excellent job with the music though. Remake remastered score is awesome.

    Upcoming XVI looks like it might have fun gameplay.
  • The Perfect Food Is Grass
    Hay is for horses and legumes (beans/pulses) are for homo sapiens. We can predigest them in our exogenous mechano guts.

    As growing plants they've added benefit of being well known nitrogen fixers, a means to more sustainable food production. Long live the Tepary bean. We may need it when all the fields have become arid.

    Long live the leguminous peanut, the most addictive of fake nuts.
  • Philosophical justification for reincarnation
    Reincarnation is no more consoling than whatever the alternatives are. When whatever pops again to call itself "I am what I am what I am" it might be another you or me. It might again carry disappointing features of its kin.
  • Type or stereotype?
    Some cultural/racial stereotypes might be primed and diffused purely by jokes with lost origins. To what extent this actually causes unwarranted prejudice or harm is a wonder.

    In Hawaii the Portguese guy was always the butt of the bar joke, portrayed as a total idiot. It seemed so bad as to convey that the only reason for creating a bar joke at all was to shit on a whole ethnicity. The elementary school yard was rife with these.

    Now ponder the historical cause of portraying the Portuguese this way:

    they (the Portugese) were second in command after the white people on the plantations. And they always referred to themselves as Pawdagees. They were under the haoles (white man) but above everyone else. They were the luna (boss), the paniolo, the guys on horseback who made everyone work. And with someone strict over them-some of them were really mean-the workers made jokes about them. That's why a high percentage of the jokes in Hawaii are directed towards the Portuguese community. — Frank De Lima...
  • Confusing Sayings
    1. Look before you leap but if you decide to leap after you've looked, don't hesitate.

    2. Many hands make light work depending upon what in hell is going on.

    3. Don't look a gift horse in the mouth until after the Greeks have left. Or look directly in the mouth of a gift horse gifted by Greeks.

    4. The squeaky wheel gets the grease because silence is golden.

    5. You're never too old to learn unless you are too old to care.

    6. Absence makes the heart ache and familiarity makes the head ache.

    7. Don't rely on idioms to mend your clothes.