The Philosophy Forum

  • Forum
  • Members
  • HELP

  • Can we turn Heidegger’s criticism of objectivity into a strong basis for subjectivity?
    ↪Angelo Cannata


    First, I have no problem with any of your posts.

    But a friendly suggestion--it could help others understand your comment if you included even a sentence or two from Heidegger.
  • Why It’s Impossible to Knowingly Sin (Objective Moral Values)
    Without a clear telos, the idea of “right” or “wrong” goes out the window. — Paulm12

    Most morality is practical. We want our streets and nation to be safe.
  • Religious speech and free speech
    On the other hand, the legal system cannot (and perhaps should not) allow or disallow speech on the basis of its consistency or obedience to the religious teachings each member claims to represent. — Paulm12

    I never said nor implied that.
  • Religious speech and free speech
    ↪baker


    Gosh. Insightful.
  • Religious speech and free speech
    On the contrary. It was the Church who was in favor of the separation between Church and State. The Church had good foresight: this separation is actually in the Church's favor. It's because of this formal separation that the State (and outsiders to the Church) are not allowed to interfere in matters of religion. — baker

    I have no idea why you're posting that to me.
  • Religious speech and free speech
    Irrelevant. — baker

    Absolutely relevant.
  • Religious speech and free speech
    Then he'll complain about his right to freedom of expression of religion is being denied. — baker

    Jesus said pray in private. We know the agenda of those who pray in public--nothing to do with the teaching of Jesus.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    The point of the PI is to show that there is not one logic — Antony Nickles

    Agree. The P.I. is not a refutation of the Tractatus so much as but an extension. Logic always has a context.
  • Which came first; original instruction, or emergent self determination?
    which is either fixed by some constant property throughout time or it’s all chaos and nothing is constant. — Benj96

    There are constants or patterns. But those rules can change in time. The universe is evolving.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    Excellent philosophical argument!
    And great joke!
    — Alkis Piskas

    Indeed.
  • Immortality - what would it be like?
    What are your thoughts on immortality and which type/ variation appeals or disturbs you the most? — Benj96

    I never understood the desire for immortality. If you have 80 years and think something is undone, they you wasted your 80 years.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    ↪Alkis Piskas


    If you need a dictionary, then you are not ready to do philosophy.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    Ethics and aesthetics are one. (6.421)

    This is true. A lot of people talking about art should pay attention.
  • Against simulation theories
    I don't understand your point. — Harry Hindu

    Not surprised.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    Do you understand what a self-refuting argument is? — Bartricks

    Yes, I do.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    So you understand, then, that an exclusively evolutionary story about our development isn't correct? — Bartricks

    I understand you are saying it. I see you presenting no evidence.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    Do you actually understand the OP? — Bartricks

    It was very easy to understand.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    who the hell educated you people? — Bartricks

    No one agrees with you.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    ↪Bartricks


    Goodnight, sweet troll.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    You made the inane observation that the theory of evolution is just a description of a processs. — Bartricks

    It is true. It is standard.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    Bit literal aren't we. I imagine you get stuck at stop signs a lot. Now: address the OP. — Bartricks

    I did. Clearly you cannot respond.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    Show me how by addressing the argument in the OP. Dad. — Bartricks

    I am not your father.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    So, you think there's no reason to think it's true? Read the OP again and try and understand what I'm arguing. — Bartricks

    You have the knowledge of an average college freshman. Show some modesty and do philosophy.
  • Intuition, evolution and God
    any case for evolution by natural selection presupposes that there are reasons to believe things — Bartricks

    No. Evolution is just a description of a process. No need to believe anything.
  • Who do you want to see as 47th President of the United States?
    Because reality can be more absurd than any fiction you can imagine.
    Place your bets, ladies and gentlemen.
    Take advantage of this before freedom of expression is also suppressed!
    — gikehef947

    Biden reelected.
  • The Death of Roe v Wade? The birth of a new Liberalism?
    5 And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, — Matthew 6:5-6

    Yes. Makes the entire Christian religion be judged by its founder.
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    Then bring in misfortune and suffering. Nature demands that we satisfy our needs all the while denying the means to satisfy those needs. How could the centrality of life (thereby its pointlessness) become inescapable pain and suffering? Perhaps the default of the human condition is one of want and its itchy and uncomfortable and we are tired of having to put salve on it every morning. — Nils Loc

    Even Jesus felt betrayed by God.
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    Have some beauty, you poor thing. — unenlightened

    At least have the courage to address someone directly. Bad form.
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    Disney films are beautiful so why do you sneer? — unenlightened

    Wow, if you're a child.
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    Do you think it grown up and clever to be miserable and unpleasant? It isn't. — unenlightened

    I did not say that. But lying about suffering is always a bad idea.
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    One can only therefore consider it as having decorative value. So try not to put ugly posts here chaps, it lowers the tone, spoils the pattern. We are born and die like flowers, so try to look pretty and smell nice if you can, while you can. Don't expect meaning, but go for beauty. — unenlightened

    Just like a Disney movie for children.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    ↪Joshs

    what is wvc ?
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    ↪Joshs


    Where? Just saying "Monk" is not telling me anything.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    Especially if that someone is Wittgenstein, and they directly state that they are doing phenomenology. — Joshs

    Post what Wittgenstein said about phenomenology. You cited Monk.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    ↪Joshs

    Good to know somebody wrote something.
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    A legacy is essentially the effects you leave behind. — Harry Hindu

    What does that have to do with the topic of this thread?
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    The point is to live each day like it's your last no matter how old you are. — Harry Hindu

    Why?
  • How do you deal with the pointlessness of existence?
    I never said that meaning and the effect were synonymous. — Harry Hindu

    Yes you did.
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    phenomenologically. — Janus

    ok
  • "Philosophy simply puts everything before us,"
    Philosophy sets things out but doesn't explain them...? — Banno

    Already said it.
Home » Jackson
More Comments

Jackson

Start FollowingSend a Message
  • About
  • Comments
  • Discussions
  • Uploads
  • Other sites we like
  • Social media
  • Terms of Service
  • Sign In
  • Created with PlushForums
  • © 2025 The Philosophy Forum