• Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Sorry, don't accept people from shit hole countries.StreetlightX

    :cry:
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    I wonder what McConnell has to say about a Supreme Court nomination in an election year?Monitor

    "Oh we'd fill it"
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Which of you non-Americans will house an American refugee?
  • Currently Reading
    I found the characters are mostly one dimensional and the writing sub-par, but it's nevertheless interesting in it's novelty, imagination, and by consequence, influence in the genre.
  • Currently Reading
    Novel actually :naughty:
  • Currently Reading
    To be honest I thought Dune wasn't very good.
  • Mentions over comments
    A ratio over one to one probably indicates trolling behavior, such as is evident with NOS.praxis

    To this point, if you have a lower ratio people likely agree with the comment.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    At least in Blade Runner they had flying cars and everyone had Ana de Armas girlfriends.
  • Mentions over comments
    Don't respond to Streetlight you'll only make him more powerful
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Covid is just going to be normalized as something people can just die from. Much like school shootings or police brutality, or even climate change despite skies that look like something out of a Blade Runner movie. Hard to believe at this point that this country can be mobilized to eradicate it, even with a vaccine which a sizable cohort will refuse to get.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Also at this point I'm perplexed at how any American can give a shit about 9/11 when you have the equivalent of one every 3 days for the last couple of monthsStreetlightX

    America's response to 9/11 was far worse than 9/11 itself - more than twice the amount of Americans died in Afghanistan and Iraq, over half a million citizens of those countries have died in the resulting wars, and at least 37 million people have been displaced as a result of the 'War on Terror'. The world, would have been far better if this country did literally nothing in response to 9/11.
  • Mentions over comments
    Don't feel bad mine is 0.8 and I would expect anyone over a 1 is pretty rare.
  • What Are You Watching Right Now?
    I rewatched Bela Tarr's 7 hour masterpiece, Satantango, in one sitting. First saw it several years ago over the course of four days. Definitely recommend viewing it in one go.
  • Currently Reading
    (they might have gotten it right this time)180 Proof

    I will not stand idly by as David Lynch and Sting are besmirched
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    But clearly, that's asking for too much, and so we get purely performative/symbolic gestures (like Pelosi et al taking a knee for a photo op), and both the violence and the protests will continue.Enai De A Lukal

    Yeah to this point the liberal bandage on a centuries old wound has been primarily symbolic. Grotesque photo ops, renaming streets (which as recently as yesterday resolve nothing), even pulling down statues of Confederates are symbolic insofar as they aren't part of wider material substantive change for the black community and the police.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    If Joe Biden or any other of these neoliberal dipshits want the fires to stop burning, the solution is simple enough: start holding police accountable for breaking the laws they're paid to enforce and killing/harming those they're paid to be protecting. The protesters are pretty clear about what they wantEnai De A Lukal

    :cheer:
  • NYC Thread
    I mean after Covid is over, I haven't done outdoor dining myself
  • NYC Thread
    Hopefully we can at least keep the closed streets and outdoor dining. The city is better without so many cars.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    I'm just going to drink heavily, watch a movie on election night, and turn my phone off why torture myself through it
  • Currently Reading
    Globalists: The End of Empire and the Birth of Neoliberalism by Quinn Slobodian (going to read this later)
    Middlemarch by George Eliot
    Critique of the Gotha Programme by Karl Marx

    Finished:
    Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 by Karl Marx (reread)
    The German Ideology by Karl Mark (just the section on Feuerbach and Historical Materialism)
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Of course belligerent mobs threaten RNC attendees as they leave the eventNOS4A2

    Counter-argument: fuck 'em
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Tucker Carlson is openly defending a 17 year old murdering protesters, I don't think people are aware of how bad things will be in November.
  • Does systemic racism exist in the US?
    Jacob Blake was shot multiple times in the back, in front of his family because cops "tHoUgHt hE mIgHt HaVe a gUn" while Kyle Rittenhouse shot three protesters last night, killing two of them, attempted to surrender with gun in hand yelling that he was the shooter was ignored by cops (who had previously thanked him for intimidating protesters and had given him water) clearly shows that systemic racism does not exist.
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    Erm.. I mean I'm the first one to encourage skepticism of mainstream history but.. pretty sure at least most of it happened lol. Kinda graduates past the "theory" stage really. Besides, wasn't your boy Marx talking about something along the lines of "the people want what they want (feels natural, doesn't feel totalitarian/government enforced) and will fight (damage people and property) for it" or some bit?Outlander

    I don't understand what you are saying here.
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    Another point I would want to make is that anthropological history is not necessarily relevant because the environmental factors are completely different now. One might for instance point to the more equalitarian societal structures of hunter-gatherers, but across the globe societies developed hierarchical and stratified societies independant of eachother as population grew larger after the agricultural revolution. I don't think that was some arbitrary fluke of history. It rather seems like it was a necessity to keep larger societies together.ChatteringMonkey

    My point was that values are multifaceted across history and are more often than not derived from alternative modes of production and the social relations that are organized around them (a point that Marx made as well). As such, contemporaries who claim that human nature is reducible to greed or competition is akin to a fish claiming that everything in under water. It's myopic.

    Personally, I detest building or theorizing about a socio-economic system or a government based on some theory of human nature that's reducible to a specific state of mind or biologically-based interaction.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    The first night of the RNC is completely unhinged
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    Aligning human nature with capitalism via immutable "competition" is to naturalize a socio-economic system that's only existed for a few centuries. It's another point of propaganda to identify capitalism and capitalist values as ingrained in humanity, while ignoring actual anthropological history that can provide alternative values for modern alternative systems.
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    "Only by forcible overthrow" doesn't seem like this "disappearance" would be peaceful. Stop trying to make Marx some kind of benign social democrat when he clearly isn't one.ssu

    Marx oscillated throughout his lifetime between violent insurrection and peaceful democratic regime change, often as a result of whatever was going on in Europe, but if you can't grapple with the fact that a 64-year-old man changed his mind here and there during the course of 40+ years of a highly intellectually active life than you demonstrably can't handle this thread
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    American is actually the greatest socialist country that has ever existed on the face of the earth. This is not my opinion, this is an empirical fact. America redistributed 4.5 Trillion dollars into the stock market. And the Pentagon cannot account for a whopping 21 Trillion dollars!JerseyFlight

    Marx would be rolling in his grave over this stance. Socialism does not equal government intervention tout court.
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    by the way, no one is forcing anyone to respond to NOS
  • Marx and the Serious Question of Private Property
    What has Marx to do with democracy?

    Marx isn't talking about democracy, especially not as an safety valve for society, but as a means for proletarian dictatorship in the class struggle. Proletarian dictatorship is a way to eradicate private property, the final goal for Marx. Marx doesn't give a shit about democracy, only if it furthers the exact cause of the proletariat:
    ssu

    Yeah what could Marx, the most prominent political thinker in the 19th century, have to do with democracy, the most contemplated political idea of the 19th century.

    Of course Marx wrote quite a bit on democracy; advocating and organizing the formation of class conscious proletariat classes and organizations, and a political form that would appear alien to most inhabitants of the 21st century, much less to those that lean economically conservative. Marx's rendition of democracy that would be of value to the proletarian class is Hegelian in concept: abolishing private property in order to socialize the benefits of productive property for the proletarian class to legitimately unite the universal (i.e. the form of government) with the particular (the interest of individuals or a class). Besides the fact that the proletarian (i.e. wage laborers) make up the majority of voting citizens it's curious that you think democracy dissolves into a literal dictatorship if a class conscious citizenry gains legitimate power and leverages it to further their own goals by reorganizing pre-existing property arrangements. In form, it's no different than a "capitalist dictatorship" furthering their own cause by destroying labor unions, overturning or blocking environmental regulations, etc.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    That Trump's approval rating is .2 points higher than it was an exact year ago during mass unemployment, a pandemic that has killed nearly 200K people, and a major recession reveals a lot about his supporters.
  • Deconstructing Jordan Peterson
    Zizek really pitied him
  • Deconstructing Jordan Peterson
    Remember when Jordan Peterson prepared for a debate on Marxism just by reading the Manifesto, which he admitted he hadn't read since he was 18
  • Kamala Harris

    how I long for sweet death
  • Kamala Harris
    Pretty obvious that Kamala is Black since the Right is already trying to do birtherism on her
  • Kamala Harris
    Her selection as VP strikes me as long term strategy by the Democratic elite to forcibly insert her as new face(ade) of the progressive wing of the democratic party, purely through her identity as black woman rather than actual political positions, at the expense of actual progressive women and men of color, in order to retain control of the technocratic/corporatist wing of the party. Despite lackluster support during her presidential run, which ended, laughably, prior to the primary election, she'll be well positioned for a presidential run and retain power for the technocrats in 2024 or 2028 through 2036 at the latest potentially thwarting actual progressive/left-wing women of color (or anyone else for that matter).
  • Biden vs. Trump (Poll)
    Oh fuck me they went with Harris as VP