The difference is that right wing incoherence is actually based in the ignorance of historical belief, and is a compromise to accommodate that - in the context of freedom of speech and opinion. — counterpunch
Clever argument, but it doesn't hold up in the face of current political realities. As you're well aware, a plenty of people on the right believe that, for example, COVID is literally not real and Joe Biden somehow stole the election. Bringing up this kind of thing fifteen years ago might have been strawmanning, but it isn't anymore-- this is a
significant portion of people on the right, including (apparently) some people in the US Senate. There's something more than a "free speech" compromise happening here. This is deceit of the masses by a demagogue.
The left's incoherence is both deliberate and dictatorial - like for example, how facts matter when talking about climate change, but don't matter when talking about gender — counterpunch
Well, yes and no. At the very least I think it's unfair to claim that facts just "don't matter" re: the left's views on gender, as
@TheWillowOfDarkness brings up. Plenty of leftists acknowledge the relationship between sex and gender, the influence of sex hormones on development, etc. A person born male is
probably going to feel like, and present as, a man. The question is how we address those for whom sex and gender feel mismatched.
That said, I am frustrated by, in no particular order: 1) The fact, in many places, people are allowed to take puberty-modifying hormones with little screening. 2) The fact many leftists refuse to even entertain the idea that the large amount of young females who feel non-binary or genderless might indicate a problem with some of the
expectations of womanhood, and that transitioning is not always the right option. (I was among said group of females.)
What is it with every conservative or moderate constantly bringing up 1984?
;) I've always thought we lived in more of a Brave New World.
I'd ask you to consider COVID-denialism and the events at the Capitol and the disturbing popularity of Q, and weigh those against some of the left's apparent doublethink. I am not convinced that the left is in any way more "deliberate and dictatorial" than the right.