• Benj96
    2.3k
    The past is determined. That much we know. What has already come to pass cannot be changed. The future however is a bit trickier. Is it pre-determined or completely uncertain/ ruled by free will?

    The present in this case is the meeting of the two ... the point at which the uncertain and ill-defined transforms into the certain and defined. It is also the point at which the conscious mind resides and looks ahead to the future and recollects the past.

    If we go by the idea that all of nature comes down to a logical interplay of set laws and principles of physics and chemistry, then the future is very much determined. We can calculate trajectories, predict reasonably accurately the weather some week or two in advance.

    However when it comes to agency and conscious decision it gets harder to distinguish. How do I know that my sudden desire to buy an ice cream is of my own free will or pre-determined. Maybe I was deficient in calcium, it was a hot day, a new parlour had just opened that I heard about from my friend and I had just been given money and perhaps all of these factors combining simultaneously meant that my desire for Ice-cream was inevitable and always going to happen.

    Perhaps the existence of the subconscious mind and the inability to be aware of all variables at all times are the only things separating us from the realisation that everything is a sum of pre-determined calculations and interactions. That free will may indeed be an illusion albeit a good one.
  • TheMadFool
    13.8k
    How will/can consequentialists predict the future?
  • I like sushi
    4.9k
    The past is determined. That much we know. What has already come to pass cannot be changed.Benj96

    Because?
  • Kenosha Kid
    3.2k
    However when it comes to agency and conscious decision it gets harder to distinguish. How do I know that my sudden desire to buy an ice cream is of my own free will or pre-determined. Maybe I was deficient in calcium, it was a hot day, a new parlour had just opened that I heard about from my friend and I had just been given money and perhaps all of these factors combining simultaneously meant that my desire for Ice-cream was inevitable and always going to happen.Benj96

    It's a terminological problem. No one acts without cause: I am free to write this post however I choose, or to not write it, but I have a sufficient set of reasons and causes to choose this post. The magical definition of free will employed to counter determinism doesn't exist except as a verbal construct, a conflation of counterfactuals with reality, motivated (as far as I can tell) more by anti-determinist sentiment than actual musings of free will in the wild. You can never choose otherwise. It doesn't even make linguistic sense to assert we can.
  • Miller
    158
    The mind is not separate from reality and it is not magic.

    Let that be your answer.
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.