• TiredThinker
    831
    How do we know what part of us puts self preservation above all else?

    What part is self identity?

    Is there anything in us that isn't ego?
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    Self-preservation is hardwired - there's little you can do about it except like in the movie where the guy manning a nuclear power station is :meh: at the multiple alarms going off all around him.

    Ego considers itself to be priority #1. Please put the oxygen mask on yourself before you try to be the goody-two-shoes on the doomed plane! Medici, cura te ipsum, first set your own house in order! I'm looking for a sick doctor! I'm in search of a bad cop! I'm dying to meet the sinner saint! :snicker:
  • 180 Proof
    15.4k
    How do we know what part of us puts self preservation above all else?TiredThinker
    We know, I suspect, by our fear, disgust, hunger-thirst, lust, anger reflexes.

    What part is self identity?
    It's the embodied continuity of autobiographical memories and social conditioning which constitutes a person's self-model.

    Is there anything in us that isn't ego?
    Everything "isn't ego" except the prefrontal cortex (which is why a prefrontal lobotomy renders most persons almost completely free of ego-driven judgments and behaviors).
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    self preservationTiredThinker

    First order of business: Help yourself.

    self identityTiredThinker

    The I is not easy to pin down! It seems to be more a matter of convenience than substance i.e. it just makes life simpler to assume there's a unique self. I've heard people say "I've changed my mind!". Never "I've changed my body!"

    egoTiredThinker

    Like I said, for every individual, the ego comes first - it's the tip of the pyramid of important stuff.

    Intriguingly, the ego has this burning desire to be part of something bigger, but the catch is it must negate itself for this. It's not about me anymore!
  • Tzeentch
    3.9k
    Is the ego really concerned with self-preservation?

    Isn't it easy to come up with examples in which ego-driven behavior is self-destructive, and purpusefully so?
  • TiredThinker
    831


    "Intriguingly, the ego has this burning desire to be part of something bigger, but the catch is it must negate itself for this. It's not about me anymore!"

    Apart of something bigger then negates itself? What examples are there?
  • 180 Proof
    15.4k
    I think "ego" is the drive (i.e. megalomania) to be bigger than everything and everyone else and not "to lose oneself in something greater".
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    I think "ego" is the drive (i.e. megalomania) to be bigger than everything and everyone else and not "to lose oneself in something greater".180 Proof

    Apart of something bigger then negates itself? What examples are there?TiredThinker

    True, true, but I was referring to how those lower down in the pecking order tend to feed their egos by associating themselves with the upper echelons of society (vide name-dropping).

    Apologies TiredThinker, I get the impression that what you had in my mind by ego is not what 180 Proof and I are discussing. To be honest the word "ego" comes with negative connotations which I latched onto almost without thinking.
  • TiredThinker
    831
    I mean sense of self and requirements of survival and thriving, but not necessarily a sense of importance. Just action towards own goals without thought of who else's needs might be missed in ones own pursuits without consciously thinking the worth of self versus not self. Maybe more of an intuition?
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    A more benign/less toxic meaning of ego then.

    I dunno, the ego seems to straddle the worlds of the imaginary and real? Is the ego/self the brain/mind? If yes how do you explain the statements "My brain tells me..." or "I changed my mind". Is this an indication that we're confused or is it the plain truth about the ego/self? Perhaps it's got something to do with metacognition. Is it that we're dissatisfied and fearful/hopeful about our selves and hence feel the need to invent an I that isn't anything we could point to using our metaphysical fingers? The ego looks at itself from a 3rd person point of view and as to why?, I haven't the foggiest.
  • Agent Smith
    9.5k
    Is the ego really concerned with self-preservation?

    Isn't it easy to come up with examples in which ego-driven behavior is self-destructive, and purpusefully so?
    Tzeentch

    Keep it comin'!!!
  • Bylaw
    559
    I don't think the ego is just or even primarly about self-preservation. I think the ego is more about self-focus. Self-focus can be good or bad or anything in between. There is a sense of what I am and what I want - which may be partly delusional. There is wanting things that help us to think of ourselves in certain ways. There is the knowing that this is me and that is you. So, people with leaky boundaries - like some people who have been sexually abused - may not know what is their own desire and what is someone else's.

    There is a tendency in some subcultures and even in folk psychology to view the ego as selfish (in a pejorative sense) and negative (only). I disagree, though values play a role here. A battered woman may need to beef up her ego and stop being so concerned about her husband's, yes, horrible childhood and fragile sense of self that leads to his violence. She is likely actually seeing situations through his eyes and needs. That's not her role in life.

    There is a lot of confusion about empathy needing one to be egoless.

    You are closest to yourself. It makes sense to prioritize many of your own needs. You are right there to take care of them.

    Egoless people are not likely to contribute as much because they are damaged and suffering. Can you have a healthy ego and help other people, care about them and even put them ahead of you in many situations? I would argue not only 'yes' but that without a healthy ego you are worse at these things, though on a physical, practical level you may sacrifice yourself and give.
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.