“I treasure the Bible. I live in it and work on it all the time. But it is not the word of God. It’s the tribal story of a particular people, and the best thing about that story is that the story keeps growing and evolving.”
— John Shelby Spong
God’s reasoning against a two-way, consenting, loving relationship. — Katiee
4: Homosexuality goes against procreation — Katiee
The Biblical teaching about what should be done to a child who curses a parent is quite clear. And quite monstrous and evil. — Art48
I wanted to work through the question of why is God would be against homosexuality. — Katiee
There's a line of thought that always looks for sociocultural / environmental reasons for taboos and you can almost always find something to cling to. — Baden
much harder to imagine that entire societies routinely followed their irrational leaders — Vera Mont
especially in costly practices like the sacrifice of cattle and male offspring, without any cultural or environmental motive to do so. — Vera Mont
And yet the taboos and commandments come from someplace. In the absence of an irrational deity, they must have sprung from the minds of men. — Vera Mont
It's conceivable that every ancient law-maker on every continent was irrational, but much harder to imagine that entire societies routinely followed their irrational leaders, — Vera Mont
What's the environmental motive for flying a plane into a building and blowing yourself up in the process? Certainly seems like a costly practice. — Baden
As I noted, it's not an all or nothing proposition. Some might be rational (like prohibitions against murder) and others not (like waving a sagebrush to ward off evil spirits). — Hanover
I ignored it because the idea of culture is precisely what you're trying to explain with something more ''rational''. — Baden
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.