You apply the thoughts onto the physical world i.e. typing, measuring, hammering, drilling, and driving ... etc. You have ideas how to use and manipulate the physical objects. But the ideas are in your head, not in the world. — Corvus
I had an idea to cut down the tree in the back garden for 10 years, but it was just an idea. The tree is still standing tall. Can ideas themselves change the world?Ideas are in the head, but ideas can change the world. — RussellA
Where about in the brain do you see numbers existing in physical form?In the same way that an idea physically exists within the brain, numbers, being ideas, would also only exist within the brain in physical form. — RussellA
Where about in the brain do you see numbers existing in physical form? — Corvus
P1 - Numbers and colours exist somewhere otherwise we couldn't be discussing them. — RussellA
The fact that we are discussing something is not the evidence for existence of something. We can discuss about the unicorn or a flying pig. Does it mean the unicorn or flying pig exist? — Corvus
"Numbers and colours exist somewhere"? Somewhere is like saying nowhere. — Corvus
I know them in my thoughts, and that's how I could write about them. I knew them as non-existence ideas, but they don't prevent me from writing about them. They don't exist. They are known as ideas.If either the unicorn or flying pig didn't exist somewhere, then you couldn't have written your post. — RussellA
It means it doesn't mean anywhere. In other words, it is a meaningless assertion.The expression "exists somewhere" does not mean "exists nowhere". — RussellA
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.