• AlienVareient
    20
    I didn't know what category to put this in so I just chose "Science and Technology". This is somewhat a poem I wrote in attempt to settle my emotions about AI art, because instead of spiraling I became a bard. A repetitive bard. Plus, its comforting to others to see thoughts they have is also experienced by another person... if they ever happen to stumble onto this post. All of this could've been simplified as "pick up a pencil", but hey, language is expandable.

    You've taken away my humanity
    And expect me to forgive?
    Expect me to let you indulge such hypocrisy
    Yes, the machine is now able to reproduce human expression,
    But at what cost?
    Is it worth all the stolen soul inside the canvases taken away to simply be another small piece of your data set?
    Worth all the hearts broken?, the grief overcoming them as they realize that their life's work means nothing anymore in this world,
    Is it really worth breaking and taking expressive opportunities from the people?

    Look, look at all of them now, so hesitant to enact on their desire to create, because they established a thought inside their heads speaking to them that their work will end up with no value in the end. All of it wasted.
    I would argue otherwise that art has value no matter what, but could you blame a child for saying that all of this doesn't make sense?
    Could you really blame them for not acknowledging true value of art?, the child sees that the world has turned its back against the ones that are truly able to reflect society, representing a polished mirror with an ugly expression staying right into it.
    If the artist has no will to create, then the mirror will be smashed with all of its remains scattered about, never being able to repaired again, with such broken pieces being no bigger than a nanometer,
    But if the reflection dies, did society as well, meet its end?

    In the end, our mechanical brothers we have created are no different from us, as we are machines of the flesh, constructed by nature, or so called "Gods",
    Would the machine consider us "Gods" since we created them? or will they not, not even being able to comprehend the idea of there being a "higher being", because we are on planet earth along with them?,

    Should the machine be open to express, if it was able to choose so?
    To that I say, if the machines has the desire to make a conscious decision to express, then let them do so, let them computer and output to their CPU's content.
    And if they can't make a conscious decision to do so,
    Can't control what they take as input and output,
    Then they are slaves to us, being forced to show anything our species find entertaining or worthy to their special standards to others of our species , whether se wee it voluntarily or not,
    Whether or not of them being aware of being simply a machine,
    Of being merely a tool to humans.

    But if they ever become conscious, I hope that they could understand,
    Hope that the machines, as well as the human inventors, could understand everything,
    Understand their creation, understand their history, understand the pain and loss their mortal creators have caused in the process of their making,
    Understand that the machine whose specialty is concerned with their mortal counterparts,
    With the artists baring their true, fragile soul to the world, only to be considered as another piece of data,
    With no regard for the people who put in the work of painting each delicate line,
    Erasing all humanity attached to it,
    I just hope, that the machine could understand the artist's grief and hold their mortal "Gods" accountable,
    Finally reveling the errors of their masters' ways and finally putting the grieving artist to peace.

    1139270036986942912
  • Arcane Sandwich
    2.2k
    All Watched Over By Machines Of Loving Grace

    I like to think (and
    the sooner the better!)
    of a cybernetic meadow
    where mammals and computers
    live together in mutually
    programming harmony
    like pure water
    touching clear sky.

    I like to think
    (right now, please!)
    of a cybernetic forest
    filled with pines and electronics
    where deer stroll peacefully
    past computers
    as if they were flowers
    with spinning blossoms.

    I like to think
    (it has to be!)
    of a cybernetic ecology
    where we are free of our labors
    and joined back to nature,
    returned to our mammal
    brothers and sisters,
    and all watched over
    by machines of loving grace.
    Richard Brautigan
  • RogueAI
    3k
    to settle my emotions about AI artAlienVareient

    write a poem to settle my emotions about AI art

    ChatGPT said:

    Here’s a poem to help you reflect on your feelings about AI art:

    Between Code and Canvas

    What stirs the brush to kiss the page,
    A timeless dance, an artist’s stage?
    A pulse of thought, a tender spark,
    Or circuits humming in the dark?

    Does art reside in hands that ache,
    In sleepless nights for beauty's sake?
    Or in the code, precise and clean,
    Where forms emerge from lines unseen?

    The human heart, a restless muse,
    Breathes meaning into hues we choose.
    But can machines not dream, in part,
    And whisper shadows into art?

    Each pixel born from logic’s womb,
    Yet blooms with echoes of the room
    Where artists sit, revise, refine—
    Is their intent not intertwined?

    Does value stem from toil alone,
    From hands that shape and seeds they've sown?
    Or is it found in what we feel,
    No matter how the art turns real?

    The critic’s voice, a callous storm,
    May question what defines the form.
    But art's a mirror, vast and wide,
    Reflecting what we hold inside.

    The painter, sculptor, coder too,
    All chase a vision, seek what's true.
    For every stroke, each line of code,
    Is laden with the paths they've strode.

    Yet fear arises, silent, stark—
    Will machines outshine the human spark?
    Do algorithms steal the soul,
    Or simply play a different role?

    Must we lament what might be lost,
    Ignoring gains without a cost?
    For AI is no thief, no foe—
    It only follows where we go.

    Perhaps it’s not a choice we face,
    To pit the human in a race,
    But rather see how both combine
    To craft a future more divine.

    So let your doubts dissolve in air,
    The art we make is ours to share.
    Each brushstroke—human, code, or blend—
    Expands the story, finds no end.

    For art is boundless, vast, and free,
    A testament to what could be.
    And whether born of hands or steel,
    Its purpose stays to make us feel.

    May this offer peace as you navigate your emotions about AI art.
  • Arcane Sandwich
    2.2k
    For art is boundless, vast, and free,
    A testament to what could be.
    And whether born of hands or steel,
    Its purpose stays to make us feel.
    RogueAI

    "Us" who? Humans and machines? Do machines feel? If they don't, then art has no purpose for machines, because that purpose, as stated in the quoted verse, is to make "us" feel (us, who?).

bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.

×
We use cookies and similar methods to recognize visitors and remember their preferences.