Now, apparently, it helps regulate the environment of our intestines. But this in turn gives no clue as to how or why or what the appendix is doing in terms of itself. — tim wood
This seems to approach an argument that says that what a thing is (if you even grant the possibility of there being a thing) is simply its description. — tim wood
...many fundamental breakthroughs in science and technology followed what Wiener called the inverse question. These are cases in which the solution precedes the identification of the question. As Meyer writes: “Many of the essential medical discoveries in history came about not because someone came up with a hypothesis, tested it, and discovered that it was correct, but more typically because someone stumbled upon an answer, after some creative thought, figured out what problem had been inadvertently solved” (2007: p.300). Often, problems solved through the inverse question approach revealed new areas of the adjacent possible, which were not even supposed to exist. An essential, but under-appreciated, mechanism of the inverse question is exaptation, which is the co-option of artifacts (or biological traits) for functions different from the ones they were designed (or selected) for. The microwave oven, the bow and arrow, the first antibiotic, antiseptic, and antidepressant are all cases of exaptation. — Serendipity Society
Same page. And as you say, there is no other appendix. Exaptation, then, not being about the appendix that is, is not about the appendix that is. Rather it is about something that is not an appendix - the history of their evolution or something like. This is the only distinction I'm making, and nothing Kantian or philosophical to it. — tim wood
the artificial barrier — StreetlightX
Yes. Just as the engineer is 'in the end' still a bricoleur, so adaptation is, if we remove all traces of teleology, always exaptation - a novel use for the chemistry of carbon. — unenlightened
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.