What grounds do you offer that could be rationally engaged with? — StreetlightX
I beg to differ. Isn't this exactly why we're here, in this forum? :wink:Rationality is not your - or anyone's - play-thing. — StreetlightX
If any speculation can be disproven — Pattern-chaser
Speculations do not need to be disproven — StreetlightX
Why do speculations not need to be disproven? — Pattern-chaser
just stories for children playing at philosophy — StreetlightX
Yes, of course. A real illusion is, of course, real. — Pattern-chaser
The point of this discussion is to ask how we deal with speculations for which there is no evidence. It seems that logic takes us so far, but no farther. And when we reach that point, we must stop. — Pattern-chaser
Yes, of course. A real illusion is, of course, real. — Pattern-chaser
I'm not saying illusions are real. Only that the components of illusion are borrowed from our perception of reality. — BrianW
As to BIV and RL, I would ask that you formulate a personal test for which to recognize the difference between reality and illusion. A kind of litmus test for the difference between the 'texture' of illusion vs that of reality. I believe you will find it impossible to mistake one for the other. — BrianW
Why do speculations not need to be disproven? — Pattern-chaser
Because rationality deals with arguments on the basis of the inferences that are soundly and validly developed in the course of those arguments. — StreetlightX
A deduction is a species of inference — StreetlightX
You could be a brain in a vat. There is no way you can tell. — Pattern-chaser
If we are having "theories" some sort of context of evidence is proposed. We are posing some sort of event or phenomena and then developing description which reflects it. These cannot be outside evidence because they are evidential claims. — TheWillowOfDarkness
We already know by our experiential lives we are not BIV. The events of my life, my experiences, my body, the interactions I have with other and everything around me, etc., these are not a Brain in a Vat-- I mean, my brain is in my skull. — TheWillowOfDarkness
So please, go ahead and explain how, for example, we can detect the "texture" of an illusion. — Pattern-chaser
BIV claims direct access to objective reality — TheWillowOfDarkness
If it's indistinguishable, then it is the same — TheWillowOfDarkness
...Another difference between reality and illusion is the multifaceted/versatile nature of reality in contrast to the one-sided nature of illusions.... — BrianW
There is no point to a position which leaves us without any sort of knowledge. It's just a waste of our time. — TheWillowOfDarkness
BIV is a truth... — TheWillowOfDarkness
There is no illusion indistinguishable from reality. — BrianW
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.