But without this moral obligation to specieshood, the killing of Harambe would be outrageously wrong, because the killing was done preemptively before any conclusive imminent threat. There was no conclusive evidence or indication that Harambe posed an imminent threat to the boy, and so the killing of Harambe is unjust. — Happiness
Unanswerable, because we don't know what it is like to be a member of another species.Is it moral to value human life over another species' life?
Primatologists Jane Goodall and Frans de Waal both stated that the child was at risk of being killed, if only because the gorilla was so immensely strong. There was, in their opinion (which is more to be trusted than any of ours) an imminent threat. — Herg
If one of your family members is a fugitive, is reporting him/her to the authorities the moral thing to do? What if that family member is a bad parent, who abused you? Would it change your action? — Happiness
Primatologists Jane Goodall and Frans de Waal both stated that the child was at risk of being killed, if only because the gorilla was so immensely strong. There was, in their opinion (which is more to be trusted than any of ours) an imminent threat.
— Herg
That is their opinion, not conclusive evidence or indication. — Happiness
Are you seriously claiming that all opinions on such a subject are equally good? Of course they aren't. Goodall and de Waal are experts in primate behaviour; you, I assume, are not. Get real. — Herg
As for 'conclusive evidence', in order to get that, the zookeepers would have had to wait and see whether the gorilla injured the child. That would have been utterly immoral and irresponsible. — Herg
Is it moral to value human life over another species' life? — Happiness
How about a dog's life over a cat's life over an elephant's life over a tiger's life? What is your justification? — Happiness
If one of your family members is a fugitive, is reporting him/her to the authorities the moral thing to do? — Happiness
If you found out your housemate/friend is cheating, is it moral to expose him/her? — Happiness
If you know your country is going to use biological or chemical weapons on innocent lives in the enermy country, which are banned by UN conventions, is it moral to report it to the UN? — Happiness
I'm not questioning the expertise of Goodall and de Waal. I'm questioning whether the principles of communitarianism can be consistently applied. — Happiness
Someone may feel it's right to kill Harambe, yet at the same time feel it's not right if the plan by his country to use biological or chemical weapons on innocent lives is not reported to the UN. In this case then, he is not being consistent: — Happiness
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.