Scientific theories can't be causal arguments if they work just as well backwards in time. — Inis
Science is the Lying Game. A good lie must mix facts with the lie; and it must really hard to expose. In Sweden they give annually the prizes to the best lies of the year. Isaac Newton invented a lie that was only exposed four centuries later, that is why we consider him one of the greatest scientists in History. When you expose a great lie, you get to try to say another whopper; and Einstein took advantage of this rule to tell his own lies. They were so damn good they gave him the Swedish trophy as the best fabrication in Chemistry. Many physicists today dream of exposing Einstein´s relativistic lie; but it´s hard because Einstein was so good a concocting falsehood. Karl Popper helped to improve the Lying Game by introducing new rules. — DiegoT
Does it always, though? Science does sometimes seem to concern itself with particular events, the conditions for which may not have been replicated at any other time or place (consider its studies of particular geological epochs, or particular events in geological history, such as the Permian-Triassic extinction).The scientific method deals with universal statements — Inis
On the surface the Earth looks approximately flat. — leo
But the statement that light travels in straight lines is an untestable hypothesis, it is not falsifiable, because you never see light as it travels, you only see light when it reaches your eyes. — leo
It could be that light travels in such a way that Earth appears spherical while it is not. At first glance that seems to contradict other theories and observations, such as that gravity is spherically symmetric, but in fact you could formulate a theoretical framework in which Earth isn't spherical, in which gravity isn't spherically symmetric, in which light doesn't travel in straight lines, and which would fit observations just as well. — leo
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.