Kant's Universalizability
  • moralpanic
    9
    Hello,

    Per the first formulation, Is Kant saying we are to universalize the action or the will? I suppose the proper way to word this question should be: Is the maxim the action itself or the will?

    My professor is not intrigued by this question the way I am. He says it's the action - which is the same as the will. It's not that I don't get his point - it's perfectly logical. Yet still, my intuition is thinking there is more to this. I can't help but think that in some instances, framing the universalization in the way of the will as opposed to the action might change the way we think about it.

    View Answer
    moralpanic Options
  • Mww
    4.9k
    ↪moralpanic


    I really do hate to rain on your parade, but there’s nothing in your post that passes a Kantian test. Never mind all the morality issues, because.....well..... intuitions don’t think. Just using that expression doesn’t bode well for your making any sense of transcendental moral philosophy.

    Action or the will? Neither.
    Action itself or the will? Neither.

    You have the reference material. Make some popcorn, ditch the social media junk.....have fun.
    Mww Options
  • moralpanic
    9
    I'm doing keto - I can't have popcorn.
    moralpanic Options
  • DeleteduserrcAccepted Answer
    2.8k
    Yet still, my intuition is thinking there is more to this. I can't help but think that in some instances, framing the universalization in the way of the will as opposed to the action might change the way we think about it. — moralpanic

    This seems like a legitimate worry. I htink the best way to draw out what you're feeling is to give an example where one of the two (action, will) would be engaged, but the other of the two wouldn't be.
    Deleteduserrc Options
  • fdrake
    6.7k
    ↪moralpanic


    The first sign of being addicted to philosophy is doing it while you're in a k-hole. The second sign is doing philosophy when you're not in a k-hole.
    fdrake Options
  • Echarmion
    2.7k
    Is the maxim the action itself or the will? — moralpanic

    I'd say the maxim is the personal principle according to which the will is formed. It takes the form of a law, which is why it can be universalized as a law.
    Echarmion Options
  • moralpanic
    9
    Thank you all. I appreciate it much. :)
    moralpanic Options
  • moralpanic
    9
    ↪fdrake


    I said keto, not ketamine. LOL
    moralpanic Options
  • fdrake
    6.7k
    ↪moralpanic


    Forgive me.
    fdrake Options
bold
italic
underline
strike
code
quote
ulist
image
url
mention
reveal
youtube
tweet
Add a Comment

Welcome to The Philosophy Forum!

Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.

Sign In Create Account

Categories