It's not false - nor is it true. It just unnecessarily eliminates possibilities. But is it correct to say that all atheists have the same view of the life/death cycle? Maybe there are differences? — Rich
I’ve dreamed of falling to my death from a great height. I’ve dreamed of being shot to death. I’ve dreamed of drowning to death. I’ve dreamed of being eaten alive by wolves. And yet despite all that, I still exist. I am clearly indestructible. — lambda
We all know no belief system is ever air tight in all respects — intrapersona
so what is wrong with the athiests perspective that there is nothing after death? — intrapersona
I think there's a lot of counterevidence to the ‘nothing happens when you die’-understanding of death.
Consider dreams. I frequently die in my dreams, and yet, here I am still existing.
I’ve dreamed of falling to my death from a great height. I’ve dreamed of being shot to death. I’ve dreamed of drowning to death. I’ve dreamed of being eaten alive by wolves. And yet despite all that, I still exist. I am clearly indestructible.
Since the waking world is a dream, I fully expect to survive my waking death in pretty much the same way I survive my dream deaths. — lambda
Do we? — Thorongil
Why is this the "atheist perspective?" The denial that God or the gods exist is not to deny that there is "nothing after death," whatever that means. You also misspelled "atheist," which additionally needs an apostrophe to show possession in your sentence. — Thorongil
Not at all, you have the panpsychist scenario:
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-consciousness-universal/ — Babbeus
I said atheism rejects a religious afterlife like that of heaven, it just so happens to be the case that EVERY SINGLE ATHEIST I have ever met also "just happens" to flat out reject any possibility of afterlife whatsoever, so if that is not saying something about the state of minds of people who believe in atheism I don't know what is (IE belief without evidence). — intrapersona
Yes, I believe there is and it manifests as inherited or ingrain skills. — Rich
This is an interesting subject. I don't deny past lives, and I'm quite open to the possibility, just that, one life would have no bearing on the other life, for the simple reason that we forget it. So my past life - whatever it was - is of no significance to me now.Aside from that, there is also the research of children who remember their past lives, although from experience on forums, I know this is generally denied in advance. — Wayfarer
it first needs to be established whether there is a meaningful phenomenological or behavioural notion of absolute unconsciousness. Otherwise "there is nothing" cannot be part of a meaningful observation sentence , behavioural sentence or abstract sentence referring to experience, qualia or phenomena. — sime
Atheism is simply the lack of belief in a God. It says nothing about what happens after death. — Maw
Cultural atheism, while rejecting theism still clings to most of the same transcendental superstitions and prejudices as judeo-Christianity, superstitions that Immanuel Kant ought to have put to rest via a grammatical banishment of all talk concerning things in themselves. — sime
Re the view of death that you're referring to--your systems simply stop functioning, so that you lose consciousness cease to exist as a sentient creature, etc., nothing is false about that. It's rather true. — Terrapin Station
It is possible that we are all evolving, very subtlety, via this form of memory. Of course, as with any memory (and any hologram), it takes lots of reinforcement. The memory is not equally strong in all areas. — Rich
Atheism, as others have noted, is only a lack of belief in gods, or a belief that no gods exist. There's not actually an "atheistic view of death." — Terrapin Station
But you can't prove consciousness is created within the brain — intrapersona
Atheism flat out rejects christianity — intrapersona
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.