Is rational thought possible without language? — bioazer
Similarly, is thought structured after our language? Do people speaking different languages think in inherently different ways? — bioazer
Is rational thought possible without language?
Similarly, is thought structured after our language? Do people speaking different languages think in inherently different ways? — bioazer
Of course it is. How do you expect us to learn language if we weren't rational?Is rational thought possible without language? — bioazer
In order to learn a language, you need to have senses and a brain to interpret the sensory signals. Language is just visual scribbles and sounds (and tactile sensations with braille for the blind). To say that we think in our language is just saying that we think in visual scribbles and sounds. We can never escape our thoughts taking the forms that they do (visual, auditory, tactile, gustatory and olfactory).Similarly, is thought structured after our language? Do people speaking different languages think in inherently different ways? — bioazer
We are designed to acquire and use language — Bitter Crank
Thought without language is most certainly possible. Artists, for example, think in terms in imagery, symbols. Language is a device for sharing thoughts.
It's not language that forms thoughts but rather it is experiences which are reflected in languages. First and foremost, it is always experiences (memories). — Rich
My preference is to define the concept of thinking so broadly that it refers to a kind of phenomenon that does not have to be accompanied by brain let alone the ability to use language. Most people, however, prefer to think in specifics, so they are inclined to define thinking narrowly as a conscious process that takes place in a brain and is intertwined with language. — Magnus Anderson
But don't those images and symbols have words without which they cannot exist; without which they cannot be thought? — jancanc
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.