For the purposes of this thread, let's imagine that I walk around all day everyday with a hair trigger loaded gun in my mouth. You try to talk to me about the gun, but I roll my eyes at your hysteria, and keep changing the subject to a thousand other topics.
Am I rational?
Would you take any philosophy I write about seriously? — Jake
Am I rational? — Jake
For the purposes of this thread, let's imagine that I walk around all day everyday with a hair trigger loaded gun in my mouth. You try to talk to me about the gun, but I roll my eyes at your hysteria, and keep changing the subject to a thousand other topics.
Am I rational?
Would you take any philosophy I write about seriously? — Jake
The hair trigger gun aimed down all of our throats is nuclear weapons. — Jake
Is professional academic philosophy basically just a scam? — Jake
Is this what you were really interested in all along? Fine by me if it was. — Bitter Crank
Were there no philosophy departments--even as elitist rackets--the knowledge of philosophy would eventually disappear. — Bitter Crank
Look at what happened over a few hundred years of the collapsing Roman Empire: piece by piece chunks of social knowledge were lost. — Bitter Crank
What is the point of philosophy if it can't even guide us to focus on the "gun in our mouth" which could destroy everything in just a few minutes? — Jake
Is there any point to philosophy beyond casual nerd entertainment? — Jake
Is professional academic philosophy basically just a scam? — Jake
It would be unreasonable to expect philosophy to guide us to a solution to the threat of nuclear catastrophe in and of itself. — Sapientia
Ok, fair enough, but I didn't ask for a solution, just interest. — Jake
1) If philosophy can't guide us even to having a serious sustained interest in the most imminent threat to modern civilization... — Jake
2) If even the most highly educated professional philosophers don't display that level of interest... — Jake
3) Is philosophy really just a parlor game? — Jake
I'm not disputing the entertainment value of philosophy, that much value at least is proven by all the people engaging in such discussions. I'm asking if there is a value to philosophy beyond entertainment. — Jake
I've asked whether academic philosophy is a scam because the many millions of dollars spent on it seems to imply that philosophy is a serious enterprise. If that's not true, if it's just a parlor game for over educated nerds, then a lot of taxpayers would seem to be getting ripped off. — Jake
I'm getting these ideas through the processes of reason, and you have yet to show why an intellectual enterprise which can't sustain a focus on the most imminent threat to modern civilization should be taken seriously, other than as a form of entertainment. — Jake
What is the point of philosophy if it can't even guide us to focus on the "gun in our mouth" which could destroy everything in just a few minutes? — Jake
Search resusts for "professional philosophers on nuclear disarmament" — Sapientia
You're not interested in nuclear weapons either. — Jake
Please explain to us why these agendas are more important than the imminent collapse of everything built over the last 500 years. — Jake
You're making my point for me. Just like the academics and other intellectual elite "experts" you're not capable of using reason to identify the most important life and death subjects. To debunk this, show us the articles YOU have written on nuclear weapons. There are none, right? That's not your personal failing alone, but rather the failing of Western culture at large. — Jake
And this is why I am asking if philosophy is really anything more than a parlor game. If even the most intelligent and educated people can not use philosophy to focus on the survival of human civilization, what good is it (other than entertainment)? — Jake
Yes I am. — Sapientia
Why do you expect me to have written articles on the subject of nuclear weapons? Do you expect that of everyone you encounter? — Sapientia
No, do your own research. I'm not your personal assistant. — Sapientia
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.