I'm not making a statement on whether or not evidence of the supernatural is possible. I'm genuinely interested in what would count as evidence for the supernatural. My only problem is concerning miracles and how they are possible.That seems pretty close to saying that the “supernatural” is impossible by definition, is that right? — DingoJones
It could be something that can't be explained by science but is not in conflict with laws of nature. In other words, it is complementary with nature not opposing it.Well isnt a breach in the laws of nature the exact thing “supernatural” is meant to describe? — DingoJones
It could be something that can't be explained by science but is not in conflict with laws of nature. It other words, it is complementary with nature not opposing it. — Purple Pond
What other examples are there that provides evidence for something supernatural? — Purple Pond
Or you could be having a psychotic episode. — Purple Pond
Supposing you were sitting there in front of your computer contemplating your next post, and you heard, clear as a bell, a voice that said "Jack Jones" (or whatever you name is) "I am god and I am real and you are not imagining my voice. — Bitter Crank
What kind of evidence could there be for supernatural phenomena? — Purple Pond
t isn't hard at all to imagine how a person immersed in a culture where it was believed that the world was infested with benign and malignant small gods could be both comforted and terrorized frequently. Imagining spirits seems like something humans are just primed to do -- unless otherwise instructed. — Bitter Crank
You mean like how there was a logical basis for the idea that the Earth was flat and the center of the universe because the Earth really is flat and the center of the universe? Oh, wait it isnt. You're simply appealing to the majority, which can be wrong. And there is such a thing as a mass delusion.There's a logical basis for the idea that vast numbers of humans have imagined spirits because something like spirits really do exist. — Jake
A more likely explanation is that humans have imaginations and adopt the norm of the society they find themselves in. — Harry Hindu
A man was climbing a mountain. He liked to climb mountains, and he was good at it. This day, however, things did not go well at all and he found himself stuck at the end of his rope and his tools somewhere far below, having fallen off his belt. The situation was not good. He wasn't going to be able to climb up or back down the rock.
He wasn't very religious. He was in a very bad fix, however, and he feared that he would die. So he prayed to God, most fervently, because he was as one can imagine, very afraid. He prayed and prayed.
Suddenly he felt a very strong Presence near him. "God?" he quavered?.
"Yes, child, I am here."
"I'm afraid I am going to die." the man said.
"Yes, I see that. But I am here."
"God, I'm sorry I've never prayed to you before."
"Yes, I know that you feel sorry about not praying." God said.
"God, I've done very, very bad things to people--things much worse than Brett Kavanaugh has done."
"Oh yes, I know what you have done -- I was there when you did those very, very bad things. I was there with Brett Kavanaugh, too."
"God, why do you want to save me?"
(God thought to himself, "Who said anything about saving this jerk? It would, though, make for excellent PR if I saved him. He's the type who will never stop talking about it. He must, however, pass a test of faith.")
"Because I love you, my child." God said.
"God, I don't see how I can make it back up the mountain, even with your help."
"I am very powerful." God said.
"Ok, tell me what to do," the man said.
"Let go."
Maybe you were having a touch of oppositional defiant disorder that day and just couldn't accept the authority of the guide. — Bitter Crank
Better to develop this problem as a child than when you grow older -- people really don't like it when adults behave that way, I've found. Especially when it persists. I developed the problem sometime around 30. Bosses tend to be annoyed when employees dismiss their authority as nothing but some sort of sham. — Bitter Crank
What kind of evidence could there be for supernatural phenomena? As an atheist I'm trying to think of examples of what would convince me that there is a god and that the physical world is not all there is.
How about miracles? ... A miracle points to a divine being with a purpose violating natural law to produce a desired outcome for certain people. The problem is that if the laws of nature could be violated then they aren't laws at all.
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.