So in your view, it's a problem to do things to any arbitrary biological matter? For example, if you have a mole that's bothering you, it's an ethical issue to cut it off? — Terrapin Station
The problem is if I somehow made the mole sentient — khaled
This=the stance you just uttered. — Terrapin Station
The problem of the suffering baby with 8 broken limbs doesn't arise before sentience either — khaled
?? If it's not okay to you, then it's an ethical issue in your view. At any rate, obviously the stance of mine that you quoted doesn't apply to nonexistent entities or to any arbitrary biological matter. — Terrapin Station
The point in time at which the issue occurs is after the baby is born with 8 limbs however that doesn't mean genetically modifying it to give it 8 limbs is ok even though the actual problem occurs later. That is because the suffering of having 8 broken limbs is causally pegablle to that genetic alteration. Do we agree? — khaled
Is it or is it not ok to genetically modify a baby so that it is born with 8 broken limbs and suffers severely for the rest of its life? under your ethical system — khaled
Re giving birth, it depends on the health of the child, whether we'd allow infanticide (which I think we should in some cases), etc. — Terrapin Station
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.