Speaking of PF members who haven't properly made it over here, I don't get why busy (busycuttingcrap) hasn't joined in, despite actually joining last year. I recall that he, along with several others, wasn't happy about the way the TPF faction abandoned ship, but none of that matters now. — jamalrob
P1: Banno is dead.
P2: Banno was Australian.
P3: The evidence here shows that he refuses to stop talking.
C: Dead Australians can talk
Q.E.D. — Brainglitch
Why "Banno was Australian" and not "Banno is Australian"? You seem to be implying that he isn't an Australian (any more). And if he isn't an Australian then he isn't a dead Australian. Therefore that he talks is not proof that dead Australians can talk. — Michael
P1: Banno be dead.
P2: Banno be Australian.
P3: The evidence here shows that he refuses to stop talking.
C: Dead Australians can talk — Brainglitch
Can the dead have citizenships? If not then you can't be both dead and Australian. — Michael
You don't lose your citizenship simply because you cease living.Can the dead have citizenship? If not then you can't be both dead and Australian. — Michael
They even vote in some places. — Brainglitch
Sometimes they vote twice and collect Social Security checks. — ArguingWAristotleTiff
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.