Suppose I believe in making decisions based on which kind of bird I see first thing in the morning, and that I believe this due to my own unpublished scientific research.
Is this an irrational belief? — Rufoid
Suppose I believe in making decisions based on which kind of bird I see first thing in the morning, and that I believe this due to my own unpublished scientific research.
Is this an irrational belief? — Rufoid
This kind of brings to mind arguments over "objective" morality and the is/ought gap. What often stands for said objectivity is some consistent reductive procedure for deciding moral questions - even if, in a deductio ad absurdum, the procedure were as arbitrary as examining bird entrails. — SophistiCat
Suppose I believe in making decisions based on which kind of bird I see first thing in the morning, and that I believe this due to my own unpublished scientific research.
Is this an irrational belief? — Rufoid
The thing about rationality, in the narrow procedural sense, is that it is completely sealed — SophistiCat
The choice of the rules and the decision to stick to them are not rational though — SophistiCat
Well I believe on the basis of walking out my front door many times that there is no danger of falling into a fiery pit if I walk out of my front door. — unenlightened
But I guess it rather depends on what decisions, and what research. If you are a hunter, it might be reasonable to base your lunch recipe on what bird you come across. — unenlightened
People who behave in the way you describe are working from a set of beliefs that they haven't subjected to scrutiny. People who reject such a worldview have. — TheMadFool
In terms of purely instrumental rationality, it's not irrational. In terms of rationality as a more general faculty of applying your mental resources in an effective (for solving problems) and non-contradictory manner, it probably is irrational. — Echarmion
Suppose I believe in making decisions..... — Rufoid
What’s irrational is seeking or expecting a verifiable objective account of a decision making process by that which is not, and can never be, a first-person perspective. — Mww
Suppose I believe in making decisions based on which kind of bird I see first thing in the morning, and that I believe this due to my own unpublished scientific research.
Is this an irrational belief? — Rufoid
As long as an approach is effective and non-contradictory, it could be called rational? — Rufoid
As long as an approach is effective and non-contradictory, it could be called rational? — Rufoid
Suppose I believe in making decisions based on which kind of bird I see first thing in the morning, and that I believe this due to my own unpublished scientific research.
Is this an irrational belief? — Rufoid
But suppose I learned this superstition from a community of white magic practitioners (it used to be common). It's been scrutinized. Is it rational now? — Rufoid
I think this is a case of ambiguity arising from lack of information that is confusing some of the other posters. — Judaka
Did it hold out to your scrutiny? After careful examination of the evidence did it establish the fact that birds can aid in decisions — TheMadFool
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.