Emotions aren't a survival tool that's why some people emotionally shut down or repress in order to navigate extreme stress. So, the question doesn't really make sense as emotions were never a matter of survival. However, not being necessary for survival is a poor measure for value.Please note that this discussion talks about the 'need' of emotions on a survival basis and not the 'wants' of emotion. — Kinglord1090
I don't believe emotions have anything to do with rationalism.
If anything, if often goes against logic.
It's best shown in experiments like the Trolley experiment, where a human would rather save 1 person with whom he/she/they have emotional connection with rather than save 4 strangers, which far disobeys logic by simply not giving a damn about 4 lives over 1 life. — Kinglord1090
Also, I think you just contradicted yourself with this statement -
"there's no way someone would ever be rational if it hurt like hell.",
as if you meant it, you are just saying that its better for everyone in the world to die, if it means you can have peace and not be in pain.
I feel like thats an excuse for saying that you are weak and/or a coward. — Kinglord1090
Science begs to differ.
If we go to the root of all emotions and desires, we are not that different from robots.
I believe that emotions an — Kinglord1090
Yes, computers and robots are not human.But the inspiration for making them was taken from human brain. Scientists tried to replicate the way a human brain works, and they ended up with computers.
Which is an undeniable proof that the way a computer works, that is, by logic, is an essential part of humans. — Kinglord1090
Here at the end is the part necessary for survival. You have framed the discussion in terms of hard needs and then claimed the emotions accompanying survival are necessary. Do they assist; yes. Do they actually move you out of the way of a train. Well, no. So, you are arguing against your own restrictive OP. As far as I can tell.....specifically designed to motivate behaviors and bodily responses — Kinglord1090
Really, you spend 24hrs in a life and death situation?Also, if anything being necessary for survival is an excellent measure for value. — Kinglord1090
Feel free to insert an overarching point any time. The argument seems to be 'my statements are incorrect' by arbitrary measure. Fascinating stuff.I don't think i need to say anymore, but i might as well. — Kinglord1090
Are you familiar with the concept of condescending discourse and how under appreciated it remains?Food and shelter on the other hand are highly necessary for survival. — Kinglord1090
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.