It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it. — Upton Sinclair
As a leftist, that's news to me. How do you know this?There is no left wing in the US. — StreetlightX
Virtue signaling, or call it what you will, compensates for the left’s inability (or reluctance) to demand genuine economic change. At the bottom of our current “heresy-hunting frenzies” is a desire for compensation, to feel politically triumphant, even if it is only in ineffectual ways. This ritual of self-celebration — typified by the “heroic” postures struck by campus radicals, cable news hosts, and career activists — has become a major part of the “political subculture of the left.” Burgis believes that this obsessive allegiance to virtue-rooted-in-identity has become pathological, whether it is found on the left or right. The arguments associated with “identity politics” are inevitably rooted in the same source: an embrace of the impregnable power of subjectivity (or to our proclaimed “subject positions,” at least) rather than a call to reason.
Bernie and AOC have done their job well.Most of the far (and not so far) left has been conned into working inside the system to change – no, reform :shade: – the system, that is, just rattling the cage of the status quo. — 180 Proof
America has long been a majority center-right country and the left (which isn't by any stretch a monolith) is outnumbered, I hazard to guess, by a ratio of at least 10-to-1. — 180 Proof
The very idea of there being an uprising is skipping steps, there isn't any other option than hard work by organizers and taking over local governments and councils, which accelerated due to the Sanders campaign. It's difficult to keep track of the work being done because we live in a continent sized country but it's there if you've been following your state politics, just don't expect to overturn the country in the next few years. — Saphsin
There is no left wing in the US. Just a bunch of effete liberals - all of whom are centre right - who confuse politeness and table manners for politics. — StreetlightX
Most of The Left do not want the mere reforms you've listed, we want to change, that is, replace "the system" – governmental & economic – completely. — 180 Proof
Specifically, we want to change the game from shareholder control to stakeholder control and not just change the rules which perpetuate "the status quo" (i.e. shareholder control). The latter are "liberals" at most, many are "conservatives" too and not what The Left consider "left", whereas the former are (radical) Leftists — 180 Proof
That's how I see things and, to the extent we disagree, Xtrix, I suspect it's more of a matter of semantics than substance, and not worth quibbling over definitions & labels for me to get my point across when I say "the Left, as far as the Anerican electorate is concerned, are outnumbered (approximately?) 10:1" IMO. If you still disagree, then let's agree to disagree on the precise ratio, but I don't suspect we disagree that to a significant degree The Left is outnumbered by, let's call them, the Center-Right + Right in the US. Or do we disagree even on that? — 180 Proof
With the rise of "Far Right Extremism" and the Right so emboldened as to storm the Capitol building, where is the Far Left's Uprising? There are forms of Left Wing radicalism apparent in the US, but none so apparently emboldened as the Right's. — Lil
You missed the Antifa and BLM "mostly peaceful" riots last summer in which at least 23 people were shot dead, — fishfry
Not enough neighbourhoods were set on fire. — StreetlightX
With the rise of "Far Right Extremism" and the Right so emboldened as to storm the Capitol building, where is the Far Left's Uprising? There are forms of Left Wing radicalism apparent in the US, but none so apparently emboldened as the Right's.
Why? — Lil
Yeah yeah, the organizers have been so tremendously successful so far. — StreetlightX
80% of the American public is "politically ignorant" meaning they are so ignorant that they can not answer very basic questions about American politics. — Saphsin
ean towards Erik Olin Wright's formulation of "non-reformist reformism" on the path to socialism. Let me know if you're sympathetic to it — Saphsin
But I’m guessing you know all this already and are just being provocative. — Xtrix
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.