Existence can be seen as stacked layers that start with art at the bottom as an emotional representation, science in the middle as analytical understanding of nature and finally philosophy at the top as a desire for truth that ties everything together which altogether creates a unique singular entity we experience as a conscious being. — seaofgems
Welcome to the boards, SeaOfGems. Please be aware that we exercise here extreme criticalism. This is typical of philosophers these days. So please don't let it get to you if people make unkind comments to your post here.
I hope you will get used to the forum's spirit of fighting very soon, and have fun with philosophy here. — god must be atheist
But surely critiquing isn't the same as criticizing. The former is directed at the subject matter while the latter is directed at a person. Ad hominem's aren't usually a part of good critiquing and for good reasons are considered fallacious. — skyblack
I shalt now endeavour to critique your opinion.
Thesis: sometime the distinction that you so aptly described, between critiquing and criticizing, disappears, and for a good reason.
1. Not everyone responds to critiquing.
2. Some who don't respond well simply ignore the counter arguments to their thesis.
3. This is very frustrating to the critics, when the counter arguments are carefully thought out and are apparently valid.
4. The critics will become abusive; they don't utter ad hominems, they simply vent their frustration and call the original offender horrible names.
00000000000000
For some reason the majority of the fallacies used in arguments come from the pens of those who defend their thesis. Most of insults come form the critics once they discover that their arguments won't stick, can't stick to the Original Poster. — god must be atheist
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.