I agree that polytheism offers more inspiration for people in terms of how they may want to shape their life. Yet, I'd say that the polytheistic beliefs have the same problem in being "beyond" human. — Hermeticus
I am looking at this from a psychological perspective and what seems to be a ‘healthier’ view. — I like sushi
Where Socrates would argue that the gods shouldn’t be followed because they err I wouldn’t agree. To blindly follow is stupidity/laziness. To observe and learn what the gods show us through narrative interactions, to understand how they become more relatable and to aspire to certain characteristics that inspire us as a individual is precisely the point of the polytheistic view of the cosmos. — I like sushi
Which makes little sense given modern scientific discoveries because in the end it all leads to one God one way or the other. — SpaceDweller
Monotheism seems less flexible and less forgiving. — I like sushi
No they're not. One is about the psychology of a particular species of animal life, one is about supernatural entities that are responsible for the creation and management of the physical world (and a supposed afterlife). — Michael
How can one entity (God) be the source of , grabbing the low hanging fruit here, both good and evil. At a minimum we need two deities. — TheMadFool
Moses Finley says they're the same (pretty much). We think of the psyche as something an individual owns. Ancient people saw the psyche plastered over the whole world and called the elements divine.
Yes, there's the mythology if the world's beginning. That's a small part of what divinity once was. — frank
So, God's just a concept! — TheMadFool
No, good and evil are concepts. — Michael
How does that make reifying relevant? Where did I go wrong? — TheMadFool
I have no idea what you're saying here. Can you speak literally and not in metaphor. — Michael
You seemed to reify good and evil. — Michael
That has nothing to do with whether or not monotheism is correct. — Michael
Any facts about the supernatural and religious cosmology are entirely separate to human introspection. — Michael
Does the "fact" that good and evil are just concepts have any consequences that I/we should be worried abotut? Since these are just concepts, am I now at liberty to murder, rape, pillage, plunder, etc? — TheMadFool
I would necessarily see a progression towards a monotheistic set up but I don't think there was, or has been, much time for it come to full fruition (in terms of what it could offer PURELY as a psychological edifice of guidance and reference). — I like sushi
only looking at it as a human phenomenon (an anthropological perspective) and viewing how it applies to human life and psychology. — I like sushi
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.