But god can do anything... — Banno
Are you dropping that now, and saying he can't friddling a bleth? — Banno
SO he can friddling a bleth? — Banno
I'm not interested in a refutation. But repeating "God can do anything" does not constitute an argument.You can't refute an argument by agreeing with it. — Bartricks
Rest assured god is at this very moment simultaneously friddling and not friddling a bleth. — ZzzoneiroCosm
Bartricks' argument places god firmly in the world of the uninteligible, the incoherent; he makes god into nonsense. — Banno
I'm not interested in a refutation. But repeating "God can do anything" does not constitute an argument. — Banno
If you say he stops being God once he creates the stone he cannot lift then you’ve effectively claimed that God can’t not be omnipotent (because in that case he stops being God). — AJJ
You don't seem to understand English or basic logic. God is coherent. That does not mean the same as 'God cannot be incoherent'. — Bartricks
A bachelor (as opposed to a particular man who is a bachelor) does not have the potential to be married, because a bachelor can’t be married. — AJJ
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.