After each verse, he includes relevant verses from the Chuang Tzu, also known as the Zhuangzi. So far, it's been really interesting and helpful. — T Clark
Finished both! So, the Mielants was not bad. Its big draw is that it's comparative across very different societies - Europe, China, India, and North Africa. Enormous undertaking, especially when packed into <180 pages. Essentially, it looks their various developmental paths in order to try and figure out why it was only in Europe that capitalism developed. His basic line is that it was only in Europe that merchants were able to gain access to state power, whereas in the other regions, the state managed to retain an autonomy from capital which prevented its proliferation. So he's (rightly) critical of the idea that the spread of markets naturally correlated with the rise of capitalism (like Wood), and he notes that it was a specifically political transformation. On the other hand, he's much more generous in locating the proliferation of capitalism in the late middle ages (~1500 or so), which is alot earlier than most commentators. The best parts of the book were his examinations of the non-European regions, especially North Africa, which I honestly have never given too much thought to. But his thesis about merchants and state-power is a bit broad-brush to me, and doesn't seem to pay enough attention to differentation of developmental paths within Europe itself.sounds good lemme know your thoughts — Maw
If you can, let me know how you find the Traverso book — StreetlightX
Just arrived - a nice set, although I wish it didn't have the Apple Tv logo on the covers. It's been forty years since I read the original trilogy. — Pantagruel
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.