Presumably the phrase "your own private thought" refers to my own private thought. — Michael
What I don't seem able to do is give a similar account of what using a word privately to refer to one's own private thought might be. — Isaac
Of course you can. So it's not private. That's the point.
A private language is one only you understand. — Banno
If "Only accessible first-person" means that one can only talk about it to oneself, then it is private in the requisite sense, and drops out of consideration.This is a basic problem first of even knowing whether similar/the same phenomena are experienced the same way because the experience is private and only accessible first-person. — Andrew4Handel
:grin: If the words only refer to things inside your head, then it's private. As in, If only you can refer to your pain, then I cannot refer to your pain. And if no one else can refer to your pain, then you are " using a language that only (you) can understand".I'm not saying that there's a language that only I can understand. I'm saying that words can refer to things that only happen inside our heads. — Michael
Is there some bizarre condition that a single word can't refer to a private though but multiple words can? — Michael
As in, If only you can refer to your pain, then I cannot refer to your pain. — Banno
It is, in Wittgenstein's example, the label given to the box. — Isaac
I'm not saying that only I can refer to my pain. You can refer to my pain as well. — Michael
That's the problem with Andrew4Handel's proposal that "the experience is private and only accessible first-person" - it implies that only he can talk about such an experience. — Banno
This is a basic problem first of even knowing whether similar/the same phenomena are experienced the same way because the experience is private and only accessible first-person.
So is the is this a resolvable problem? — Andrew4Handel
'The many dwell in their own private world, whilst the awakened have but one world in common' ~ Heraclitus (quoted in John Fowles, The Aristos). — Wayfarer
That's the problem with Andrew4Handel's proposal that "the experience is private and only accessible first-person" - it implies that only he can talk about such an experience. — Banno
But that's not right...
Migraine
pounding
pulsating
“sick” headaches (due to associated nausea)
throbbing sensation
Tension headache — Banno
If two people have headaches there is no way of comparing whether both of them are having the same type of pain. — Andrew4Handel
So is the is this a resolvable problem? Does this mean we are closed off from others in some kind of profound way?
I think it is all a problem form brain correlations because if you can't define something accurately how can you correlate it? — Andrew4Handel
If two people have headaches there is no way of comparing whether both of them are having the same type of pain. — Andrew4Handel
So is the is this a resolvable problem? Does this mean we are closed off from others in some kind of profound way? — Andrew4Handel
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.