Comments

  • The Musk Plutocracy
    But at least part of the 2008 financial crisis was due to the perverse incentives faced by massive government run banks,Count Timothy von Icarus

    What massive government run banks? The only government run bank is the Fed.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Let’s see what comes of it.NOS4A2

    They could build a golf course through the graveyards where 70% of the dead are women and children.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Out of all his pie-in-the-skies this is Trump’s worst idea ever, sure to set the region on fire and send all involved into a spiral of evil. The only way he can redeem himself is if this turns out to be some negotiating tactic.NOS4A2

    That is the craziest shit I have ever heard. Let's do it!!
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    When you're cost cutting, that's also a good time to eliminate entities that may have harassed you in the past, and those who might one day. They have a list of good guys to put in slots. Just sayin.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Canada is a fine place, and may it continue as a sovereign nation forever. Even so, I don't quite see Canada as the escape hatch for anyone's existential threat. Even less so Greenland. Besides, Trump and his allies will be dead long before much more ice melts off of Greenland's chilly shores.BC

    What's your theory on why he wants Canada and Greenland? I just assumed somebody told him that both those areas will be prime real estate in the future.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Perverse visionaries!BC

    He didn't have any ideology the first time around. He does now. That was my point. But you know the European aristocracy said the same thing about the founders of the Enlightenment. Perverse! History is written by the...
  • Disagreeing with Davidson about Conceptual Schemes
    I'd suggest rather that Davidson would say reference has a function only within broader theories of truth (or meaning), and there can be no coherent theory of reference per se. Reference is not free-standing.Banno

    I'll have to think about that.
  • Disagreeing with Davidson about Conceptual Schemes


    I was thinking along these lines (imagine Quine and Davidson discussing reference):

    Quine: Because differing conceptual schemes could be in play, reference is inscrutable.

    Davidson: But if there were really differing conceptual schemes, they would have to be incommensurate, because otherwise they would be translatable. And if they were truly incommensurate, you wouldn't be able to detect that.

    Quine. I don't disagree with that. I didn't say anything about detecting differing conceptual schemes, I was saying that they could exist. It's the mere possibility of it that makes reference inscrutable.

    Davidson: Oh. But you have to assume that reference is fixable in order to communicate at all.

    Quine. That may be, but it doesn't change the fact that you don't really know. The appearance of knowing is coming from familiarity with behavioral cues.

    Davidson: And this convinces you of behaviorism?

    Quine. Sort of, not exactly?
  • Arguments for and against the identification of Jesus with God
    The notion of god is inconsistent.

    Anything follows from an inconsistency.

    Therefore Jesus is God.
    Banno

    :lol: He's also not God.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    This and other examples of “humanitarian aid” has proven a wasteful and corrupt system.NOS4A2

    :up:
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    When you said that your old world had disappeared, you sounded excited by the prospect of a new one.Paine

    I loved what I thought the USA stood for. I'm broken hearted. This isn't really the place for that kind of expression though. It would be like crying into a pool of fucking sharks.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Does this dream of Manifest Destiny promise to bring the old USA back?Paine

    Step back and try to understand what's happening as if you're reading a history book. Be the psychologist, the anthropologist, the philosopher, etc...
  • Arguments for and against the identification of Jesus with God
    Issues in Philosophy of Religion and issues in theology are not mutually exclusive, at least not necessarily. Can you prove that they are?Arcane Sandwich

    I'm not inclined to debate the issue.
  • Arguments for and against the identification of Jesus with God
    It's Philosophy of Religion.Arcane Sandwich

    No, it isn't. It's a theological issue.
  • Arguments for and against the identification of Jesus with God
    It's Philosophy of Religion.Arcane Sandwich

    No, it isn't. It's a theological issue related to fact that some early Christians were Neoplatonists.
  • Arguments for and against the identification of Jesus with God
    It is therefore in the interest of Christian philosophers to argue that God and Jesus are indeed identical.Arcane Sandwich

    There were Christian sects that didn't believe that Jesus was God, the Arians, for instance. Those groups died out and the Catholic view became standard. There are Christians today who don't think Jesus is divine, like the Jehovah's Witnesses. So it's a sectarian issue, not a philosophical one.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    You guys are still not convinced climate change is an existential threat? Well I guess we'll find out the hard way if there are limits or not.unenlightened

    Why do you think he wants Greenland and Canada?
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    I think the more serious problem with democracy is that it mandates short-termism in policy. Any problem that can be kicked down the road by 5 years isn't worth the cost of solving, any investment that won't show a profit within 5 years is not worth making. Either is liable to be an expensive free gift to one's opponents.unenlightened

    As long as the Soviet Union appeared to be an existential threat, the US government could be consistent over time. As a lone superpower, there are no limits on anything.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Always happy to help.unenlightened

    :smile: Cutting costs is a veil for eliminating opposition.
  • The Musk Plutocracy

    And Trump's approval rating is at an all time high. This is what Americans want.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Wow. There's a lot of strong emotions about this.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    Have a nice lifeWayfarer

    Thanks for the blessing. I am having a nice life.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    You sound remarkably sanguine about it.Wayfarer

    I feel like the USA I grew up in is gone. It seems alien to me, but I think Trump's vision of securing Canada and Greenland is genius. I know how weird that sounds, but it is, partly because of climate change and partly because the Yellowstone caldera is due to blow up.

    The presence of Musk, Vance, and Vought signals that visionaries are gathering around Trump. Musk wants the US government to help SpaceX. Both Vought and Vance want dictatorship. A dictatorial USA will be stronger and more flexible than the old version. That's why all democracies eventually becomes monarchies, historically.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    So let’s get rid of it.Wayfarer

    I believe we're watching the emergence of an authoritarian state spanning North America and Greenland. This kind of thing happens all the time in history books. I've never seen it in real life though.
  • The Musk Plutocracy

    There's a bunch of those. They're all pretty funny.
  • The Musk Plutocracy
    No good trying to kick into the long grass of ruminations about democracy.Wayfarer

    No, it's true. The US has struggled with the problem for decades. There is no solution within the framework of democracy.

    It’s your breakfast they’re going to be eatingWayfarer

    I doubt it.
  • The Musk Plutocracy

    In a democracy there is no way to limit government spending. Only an entity who does not answer to the people can do that. It's kind of bizarre that it's Elon Musk doing it, but there you have it.

    This fault in democracy is something the human race has yet to resolve.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    But in the end, it's the Americans themselves that have to pay the price.ssu

    Most of the wood Americans use comes from Canada. Canada doesn't require the sustainability rules for harvesting wood that Americans do. It would benefit the planet if the US stops buying Canadian wood altogether. I'd like to see that happen, actually.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    I think the point is to convince these governments to help tackle the problem, which is apparent in all countries involved.NOS4A2

    Right. Maybe have the countries that are dependent on us stop fucking us over.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)

    The US was an oddity. Countries don't usually behave magnanimously the way it used to, giving out aid, supporting the UN, fostering democracy in the world, etc. I think that was just a leftover from the Cold War when some sort of ideological war was supposed to be playing out. It's time for the US to revert to the way countries usually are: selfish, ruthless, aiming to literally destroy competitors rather than creating a level playing field for all.

    Plus, it's pretty well established that the US government used to accept drug imports in order to crush noisy sections of the population, so it's significant that fentanyl abuse was highlighted. I wonder if that came from Vance.
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank
    Judeo-apathy would be a good descriptor.BitconnectCarlos

    For what?
  • Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank

    What about being apathetic about Zionism? Is that Judeo-apathy?
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)

    Specifically, Trump wants to make Canada a state. 90% of the Canadian population lives on the border, and from what numerous Canadians have told me, a lot of Canadians want to cross over and live in the US. So Canada might depopulate when Trump gets his way.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Anything is better than being tethered to the British crown.NOS4A2

    You can say that again!
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)

    You guys will probably be annexed after Greenland.
  • Climate change denial
    Why don't you have faith that new technology will solve the problems associated with climate changeAgree-to-Disagree

    Seems ominous that we haven't heard anything about fusion lately. :worry: But there's the thorium reactor. Maybe.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)


    I support life in all its forms. :love: