The cancelling that I am seeing is coming from the MAGA government right now -- federal agencies banned from talking about climate change, educational institutions not allowed to criticize Israel, journalists banned from the white house for being critical of Trump, museums made to remove mentions of slavery, or Trump's impeachment. Lots more if I just google around.
There's nothing remotely comparable on the left.
Since you're so against cancel culture, do you condemn all of this? — Mijin
1. As far as the federal government limiting what the federal agencies do and say - that is called: how it works. That has nothing to do with speech rights in the public sphere. So all of the agencies changing websites and spending money differently and deprioritizing X for sake of Y - go vote according to your own priorities. So nothing systemic to address there. No new fascistic takeover - the EPA, the white house website, NASA, Dept. of Agriculture, always bowed to the whims of the president and Congress and those debates are not "shut-down" - the woke members of Congress are being forced to make a better case.
2. Educational institutions - generally, since the 1960s, a safe-haven for all things revolutionary, and all things anti-tradition. The default in the institution: if it speaks "truth" to "power" let it speak. But they are such bad judges of what is "truth" and who has "power" and who is "victim". These institutions totally botched their students' reactions to the Israeli war. You say college institutions are not allowed to criticize Israel. That's not the message. It's that college institutions are not allowed to endanger their Jewish members. College institutions do not know how to debate without seeking to crush their opponents, and remove them root and stem. The general university consensus was, Israel has no leg to stand on, so there is nothing to debate. Just shout and speak of a new map "from the river to the sea". There is not enough acknowledgment of the responsibility Hamas has for the predicament of the poor Palestinians. There is not enough acknowledgment that Jewish people need protection and support too, as they did on October 7, 2023. So the move against educational institutions is to level the playing field, not put down the supporters of Palestine. It is a move against the tactics that endangered Jewish individuals, (US citizens versus US citizens not being handled well by the institutions). Plus, college professors have no actual guts - speak your mind and defend your arguments. What injustice is being fostered in the US on US campuses because of the federal government? You don't get easy money for stupid crap for the time-being?
3. Journalists, or opinion makers? Newspeople, or propagandists? Journalists have plenty of power and voice - more than enough to sort the issues there. They instead want to cry about "oppression" and loss of "freedom". That's more bullshit. We all know more about what Trump is doing than we ever did about what Biden was doing. Journalists are not being shut-down. If this one journalist gets shut-down, or that one news agency gets kicked out, there are 50 more to take their place. It's more a market reaction to bad journalism than it is government censorship. Again - wokeists, grow some guts. As the video from 1993 showed, Trump could have run on the same anti-woke platform 30 years ago, and he might have won then. Anti-woke cowards have all but lost the debate (that never happened) - Trump led the "no more bullshit" charge - "make your case!" Finally, the woke need the guts to make their case. Being kicked out of the white house press room is not censorship when 50 people remain in the room. If all 50 people become too afraid to challenge the president, that's on them, that's cowardice.
4. Museums - kind of silly. It doesn't erase history to pick and choose what is highlighted in a museum funded by the federal government and what is not. No one is going to forget slavery, and everyone needs to learn just how horrible it really was. But there are presentations that leave you hating America, put on by the federal government, funded by taxes from families whose children died preserving our country. There is a time and a place, and if done with true equity, the mistakes of the past can and should be presented in museums - but the inmates took over the asylum my friend and a correction might take a bit of the favored method of revolution.
There's nothing remotely comparable on the left. — Mijin
There are so many progressive takeovers of cities, towns, counties - they shut down basic land management, and we get monster forrest fires, in the name of protecting the climate. They want to include trans, so they exclude cis-gender. They want to include black women, so they exclude white men. It's been happening with great progressive success for 40 years. To the wokeist, I must be living in a different world. To me, I am trying to see the benefit of woke policy and can't find it.
What is being canceled today is 'cancellation and oppression with no debate' - so you cancel a cancelation and you don't have the same thing at all.
Since you're so against cancel culture, do you condemn all of this? — Mijin
I'm positively sure there are some injustices being committed in individual cases. I would condemn that. I don't condemn these sweeping policies that are more of a course correction away from oppression. But depending on the individual case, and because I know the nature of people, I'm sure there is much to condemn coming from "Maga" (as if a monolith).
I am against political ideology guiding individual actions. Political ideology should guide political debate. When it comes time to act - do what you think is best and be brave about it. If you are challenged, stay brave and defend your reasoning. Don't rely on a party platform to justify who you are and what you do.
So if you bring me individual cases and allow me to gather all of the facts and allow me to push back on presuppositions and "dog-whistles" and "slippery slopes" and "conspiracy" - I'm sure I would end up agreeing on what is clearly injustice and what is not.
Do you condemn me for not offering blanket condemnation for what Trump's federal government has done to websites, the press room, college funding, the climate change debate, and museums? Is all lost for the progressive victims, or can they just restate their case and show what value has been lost because of Mage, and what value needs to be restored in these arenas??