Comments

  • Leftist forum
    Ok, here's the next question. When are you going to find some outlet other than a philosophy forum for such oh-so dramatic little high school statements? How about reddit, facebook, twitter or any one of a thousand other places? Why do you have to do it here?Hippyhead
    :up:
  • Leftist forum
    Probably because neither fascism and nazism have anything useful to say about the dominant economic systemBenkei
    Except that China's government lead economy has done quite a lot, which in my view comes close to fascism. But of course, they see themselves as genuine marxists while nobody of the leftists on this forum see them as that (which is hilarious, actually). But hey, who cares what the actual people say to be these times.

    His labour theory of value is a continuation of Adam Smith and Ricardo.Benkei
    His labour theory is a disaster.
  • Leftist forum
    Warning: this is a leftist forum and you will be attacked unceasingly if you disagree with them.

    Edit: correction, the forum is dominated by leftists.
    Brett

    Naturally any Philosophy forum has for ages been dominated by leftists. Marx simply is such a big part of contemporary philosophy, so the leftists have been always part of the philosophy circles. And even if marxism-leninism isn't so popular anymore, it's totally OK to promote and talk about a philosophy that has lead to hideous totalitarianism and mass murder (unlike fascism and national socialism).

    What just has happened is that the tensions have gone up and the unfortunate low standards of social media have influenced writing here too. The present toxic atmosphere in public discourse hasn't been kept away from this site, unfortunately.

    Yet if you aren't a leftist, I think PF is the perfect forum to interact with reasonable leftists. And actually not all are leftists here...
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    That's the disgusting part of this. As I said, Cruz has already referred to his former supporters as terrorists. Yet on the other hand, there of course will be absolutely no "healing", no rapprochement, nothing of that sort what Biden earlier talked about.

    And of course for the conspiracy theorists, the reaction from the government will be the proof that "they were all along right".

    I think the next phase is that we will really start to see a dose of true terrorism as the delusional fringes of the Trump crowd believe that the civil war has already started in Weimar America. Terrorists live in their hallucinations. It's only going to get worse, actually.

    Wonder what the Covid-era, post Trump insurrection-era inauguration will look like. Talk about security then.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Hasn't Trumpism or cult-politics proven to be a failed strategy to maintain power? The Republican Party lost the White House and the majority in both chambers of Congress in only 4 years.praxis
    Certainly. That is how crazy things are now in the GOP.

    People like Howley and Cruz may be power-hungry but they're not cult leaders who can spin a web of fantasies and lies that can capture Trump supporter's apparent appetite for faith-based leadership.praxis
    Yet that's what it has come down to in the Republican party: to appease these fringe elements that have taken over the party. Anything that the majority of Republicans believe will be their line. Or they could chosen the Mitt Romney road, which they didn't. Somebody like Cruz might otherwise appear totally normal say rational things, but he will go with the crazy ideas permutating in the Trump party. Because crazy ideas are permutating in the Trump party.

    I think they bet that Republicans (and Americans in general) are separated in their own echo chambers who don't remember anything that happened six months from now. They will talk the lines people in these echo chambers want to hear and then totally turn their coats when the wind changes. They want to engage the anti-establishment crowd even if the crowd isn't rational. Because what was said a week ago doesn't actually matter.

    For example, just look at what Ted Cruz is tweeting now:

    What happened at the Capitol was despicable and horrific. Each and every one of those terrorists need to be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

    This from the senator that pushed for an "emergency audit" and made the following joint statement with other Republicans, despite requests from his own Senate leader Mitch McConnell that Republicans refrain from challenging the certification:

    The election of 2020, like the election of 2016, was hard fought and, in many swing states, narrowly decided. The 2020 election, however, featured unprecedented allegations of voter fraud, violations and lax enforcement of election law, and other voting irregularities.

    "Voter fraud has posed a persistent challenge in our elections, although its breadth and scope are disputed. By any measure, the allegations of fraud and irregularities in the 2020 election exceed any in our lifetimes.

    Hence those who indeed believed that voter fraud and irregularities exceeding any in our lifetimes are now terrorists. And if Trump falls from favor of the Republicans, likely Cruz will say that he fought hard to prevent the excesses of Trump. Everything is as malleable as that.

    That's how it works. That's how Trump works. Because past words and past actions don't matter at all.

    Josh-Hawley-Ted-Cruz-Congress-Vote-Certification-825x400.jpg
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    In reaction to Trump his denouncement of the violence last Wednesday. :rofl:Benkei
    As I said earlier, Trump will f**k his lunatic supporters in the end. He naturally doesn't mean anything he says. Hopefully the idiots will get the memo, but it's unlikely.

    And of course the lies keep on coming, like that he called immediately the national guard to intervene (which actually happened I guess after 1 1/2 hours by the secretary of the army...or someone like that in the administration).

    So why was Capitol Hill taken over?

    D.C. officials knew of the planned protests and had requested some assistance to help when the "first amendment demonstrations" were planned for January 5 and 6, McCarthy said. Based on this request, officials called up 340 National Guardsmen to help in the peaceful protests. The guardsmen were assigned mainly to traffic control, Metro crowd control, some logistics support and a 40-member quick reaction force to be based at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland.

    "No other requests were made," the Army secretary said.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Plurality of political parties is the natural safety valve in a democracy. A system of two parties has integral problems right from the start.

    Our current popular populist hates women, which is always a nice way to alienate 80% of women.Benkei
    Nice for you! The "reasonable" yet devoted populist is the worst possible politician.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    At least for now, Benkei.

    As the saying goes...

    Yes we can too!
    barricaden-around-squatting-in-vondelstraat-amsterdam-cracker-sleeps-on-barricade-date-march-1-1980-location-amsterdam-noord-holland-keywords-barricades-squats-2APE728.jpg
    16036116_3726645.jpg
    5f4da07da310675e209b0e7c.jpeg
    820c8a34-3be6-5ab1-840e-72ce6fa7dcfd
    images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTSIbs2n2qTbTob40_sl8rE8xM_LRY2QkrLYw&usqp=CAU
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    You’re probably right here. It’s possibly similar in Europe. I’m not sure about that.Brett
    This is what I'm worried about, because we Europeans really ape all things that happen in the US.

    Especially the local media copies very often the American discourse and puts it into the domestic setting, however different the European country actually would be from the US. Something that is trending in America will get people want to have it here too. Trumpian populism is already popular in many countries. And demonstrations in the US are extremely popular than some local petty problems: just notice how the George Floyd demonstrations and riots spread to other countries (not only the UK) is very telling. Greater cause when it's happening in the US. People will try to find the equivalent sides to portray similar US positions in their totally different European setting. Who cares for things like that the US has a totally different history from ours.

    Parliaments as semi-open public places are lucrative perfect targets. Usually their security measures focus on checking the people going into the balcony (or similar place) to watch the proceedings. Yet just walking from a main door through couple of doors means that and you are likely inside the chambers of the Parliament. Parliaments usually aren't build as let's say Military Headquarters, that have been built to shut areas from outside and not be open. If demonstrators storm the Parliament, that will be an event for the history books and far more noteworthy than your typical demonstration turned a riot with looted storefronts and burned cars. Those happen ever so often in some countries.

    . Obviously violence doesn’t work because it frightens people.Brett
    I think many are just happy with that. Some even here think violence is justified as a tool for demonstrations and that peaceful protests don't work.

    BLM, BLM-supporters, Environment activists, Senate Invaders

    Same shite kind of people. Persons that due to too much or too little money in their families focuses energy on other stuff than their daytime 9-5 work.
    Ansiktsburk
    Why do you assume that they have a daytime 9-5 work?

    Have you seen the stats for unemployment these days during the pandemic?
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    , both can happen.

    Sure, Trump will be there on Newsmax and perhaps even on Fox commenting and repeating how he was swindled from an election victory (the line he already had ready for the 2016 elections), but honestly the media will get interested about Trump only if he is put on trial and faces prosecution after January 20th. Who cares what he tweets, if he gets back his twitter account?

    The place where Trump actually wants to be. Or something similar:
    origin.jpg

    In 2024 Trump will be even more toxic to a large segment of Americans than Hillary was. So that's the future of Trump. What can happen is that many will try to take the legacy of Trump in order to get his followers, or the remnants of his followers. In the end too many people will be tired of Trump. But he won't be discarded as Sarah Palin or the Bush clan.

    Young politicians who are interested in the legacy of Trump:
    5e8f6d65c023205b7845e76b?width=700

    And secondly, the polarization will thrive, even without Trump. Nothing will change that.

    Haven't we seen how American grass root movements evolve already? First it was the Tea Party, which morphed to Trump supporters, who morphed to Q-anon supporters and into the mob that ransacked Capitol Hill. On the other side you had first the Occupy Movement, which morphed then to BLM and antifa supporters. In fact, that few people call themselves antifa and are there to fight the fascists itself shows where this all is going.

    What you are looking is something like a Weimar America. It's already here, Americans are already living it. If the roaming street gangs in Weimar Germany were the Nazis and the Communists, you already have the American versions of them going around. And they will just further alienate themselves from the democratic process. Sorry to say it, Biden won't stich up this.

    Purpose in life for a few, that won't "go home". The few who will dominate the media scene in an otherwise peaceful US:
    befunky-collage-2-1601480808.jpg

    Let's remember that storming of the Capitol Hill was a continuation of a tactic that we had already seen during the Covid demonstrations in Michigan. The mob of the street is now well entrenched to US politics. It works. It get's publicity. Hence, it won't go away.

    Anyone remember Michigan?
    https%3A%2F%2Fd1e00ek4ebabms.cloudfront.net%2Fproduction%2F8f75f452-ef90-45d2-a84e-bf1ba9f228c5.jpg?fit=scale-down&source=next&width=700
  • The Road to 2020 - American Elections
    40 percent of Republicans polled approved of the Capitol mob attack.frank
    Which is a minority of Republicans, of people that voted for Trump.

    I think that a major reason why both Kelly Loeffler and Perdue lost the Georgia was because they both jumped on the Trump train. Q-anon beliefs gets a minority excited, but annoys a lot of conservatives Republicans, who all are now called RINOs.

    Republicans simply don't see how stupid and counterproductive it is to support Trump. But I guess that they think that people will forget.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump has completely f***ed himself now. He will forever be outcaste on account of what he did yesterday. The remainder is only denouement.Wayfarer

    Not yet, actually.

    In the next act he will f***k his most loyal supporters I guess.

    You notice the Trump recovery effort is already beginning. Media from the White House is now beginning to appear, 'condeming' the 'dreadful violence' and 'appealing for peace'. Trump has purportedly acknowledged for the first time he won't be serving a second term, which is the nearest he will ever get to a concession. DON'T BE FOOLED - this is desparate damage control from the bridge of a sinking ship. After yesterday's disgrace, Trump must be held to account, those vandals who stormed the Capitol Building - many of whom can easily be located via social media - tracked down and penalised, and his political enablers expelled from the Republican Party. And Trump should be removed from power immediately.Wayfarer

    I guess now, with only a few days to go, the Democrats will finally change their rhetoric and actions more to the way the GOP has operated at least since Clinton. Which...actually tells a lot about the democrats.

    And likely if (a big if) they get Trump on this, the likely outcome will be that Trump will throw under the bus his most staunchest supporters.

    Oh, but they were antifa posing as Trump supporters....right.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    No, this was certainly not a terrorist. And quite frankly if people honestly believe the election was stolen, this reaction would be totally understandable.Benkei

    And that is why Trump and the Republicans kissing his ass are responsible here for everything.

    Because for them it's just 2020's political rhetoric. They know they don't mean it for real, which makes all this utterly crazy and in the end a real tragedy. If the election really would be "stolen", then it is totally logical to take up arms, to breach Capitol Hill. But no. Oh how Trump loves his supporters, but "now they have to go home". Just like that. And they shouldn't oppose the police. And mind not destroying or vandalizing anything on the way. Yet just earlier inciting them to walk to the Capitol, which his supporters living in la-la-land aptly did, tells how out of touch this President is from what he is doing.

    As I said, this really is as bizarre and delusional as if my country's President would, just to feel vindicated and to get political points, would start accusing that the Russians have invaded the country. And then when reservists would start to gather around military bases to form units and get their weapons, he would the say to them to go home. So the Russians are invading, but no need to really gather up the Russians, mine the channels, form the brigades. That's the messaging here.

    This is really the absurd state where the US is now where delusional beliefs not only survive, but cherish. Yes, the information apocalypse is here, as you said. The Trump message is that 1) There democracy has been taken away (that's what stealing elections means), but 2) don't do anything about it, go home now.

    In the end, it all just breeds more alienation, polarization and distrust in the democracy of the Republic.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    One thing is obvious.

    The US won't heal, as Joe Biden would want it to.

    The polarization will continue, the alienation will continue. The fringes will continue to dominate the scene (at least in the minds of people when thinking of those on the other side). The silent majority will stay silent. Trump has really helped polarization a lot.

    And I think this will just slowly continue to erode American's belief in their own system. Demonstrations, protests and denials of election wins will have that effect.

    Listened to great current interview from Jonathan Haidt, who in my view made good rational comments. One thing what he mentioned is the obvious generational gap. With older folks and with Biden's generation, domestic politics could be heated, but Americans could unite especially once on the international scene as there was a Cold War going on. However the younger generations have seen only dismal US invasions, hence they don't share that kind of patriotism anymore. And of course no Soviet Union or Marxism-Leninism, hence the left/right divide is seen differently.

  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    The tragedy of the situation is that so many millions of people have been sucked into his vortex of delusion. That’s the real sickness of American society.Wayfarer
    And the tragedy is that the cynical (and fearful) Republican politicians simply cannot fathom that going with the polarizing rhetoric that has earlier "rallied the supporters", starting from the "Lock-her-up" chants and that have ending now with "Stop the Steal", has truly some other effect than just to get people to turn up vote for them in the elections. It's as the politicians don't understand that their bellicose and vitriolic accusations would and could truly create a tragedy. Yet when you depict someone to be the enemy, some simpleton or delusional person will really think so and respond how one deals with real enemies.

    In other Third World countries such rhetoric from the elections losing President that Trump has used would have already brought it down to a small civil war with urban combat in the Capital where tanks and combat aircraft are used.

    Yet Trump lives in his own delusional TV World where he can say whatever and if things really get bad, he might settle the issue out of court. This all is so obvious from Trump now begging his own supporters simply to "go home". And of course, respect monuments.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    The man is an incomparable idiot.Kenosha Kid

    Yep.

    Now Trump is saying that the election was stolen... but now go home.

    The guy simply doesn't understand just how seriously his followers take him. And likely that will be the end of Trump once those hardcore supporters understand how full of bullshit their idol is. Because, in the end Trump cannot be anything else but the inept leader that he is.

    (It would be like saying to us Finns that Russia just invaded your country, but go home now, no need to mobilize the army.)
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Really? When was the last time the US Capitol Building was stormed by armed insurrectionists stopping the certification of Electoral College votes? Perhaps you could jog my memory?Wayfarer
    Puerto Rican activists in 1954 showed the example: see 1954 US Capitol shooting.

    Boston-Daily-Globe_Mar.-2-1954-p.-15_1.jpg

    Of course then it was a normal day...
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Oh come now, there's been far worse behavior, but that's not to say that this behavior isn't especially bad. The streets burn every time there is any feeling of unfairness, real or perceived. Everyone always feels justified when they riot. What you're experiencing is how a riot looks when you find the rioters entirely unjustified.Hanover
    Now you sound like BLM supporters in the summer when explaining the looting.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Oh, no, that was sarcasm. :wink:Baden

    The current problem in American politics in 2020-2021: you don't know when people are sarcastic or not.

    And Trump, the TV bully, now getting a little bit frightened and tweeting:

    Please support our Capitol Police and Law Enforcement. They are truly on the side of our Country. Stay peaceful!

    You know, for Trump it's all a TV show, which doesn't matter in the end.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump's latest plan is to get Pence to just announce that he won instead of Biden tomorrow. Pretend he can't count. That'll work.Baden
    Think so?

    Vice President Mike Pence on Tuesday told President Donald Trump that he does not have the authority to block certification of President-elect Joe Biden's win when Congress meets to count electoral votes, sources told CNN.

    I think that Pence isn't in the crazy crowd. We'll see soon.

    Interesting that ALL living former secretaries of defense issued a joint statement, both democrat and republican ones:

    As former secretaries of defense, we hold a common view of the solemn obligations of the U.S. armed forces and the Defense Department. Each of us swore an oath to support and defend the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic. We did not swear it to an individual or a party.

    American elections and the peaceful transfers of power that result are hallmarks of our democracy. With one singular and tragic exception that cost the lives of more Americans than all of our other wars combined, the United States has had an unbroken record of such transitions since 1789, including in times of partisan strife, war, epidemics and economic depression. This year should be no exception.

    Our elections have occurred. Recounts and audits have been conducted. Appropriate challenges have been addressed by the courts. Governors have certified the results. And the electoral college has voted. The time for questioning the results has passed; the time for the formal counting of the electoral college votes, as prescribed in the Constitution and statute, has arrived.

    As senior Defense Department leaders have noted, “there’s no role for the U.S. military in determining the outcome of a U.S. election.” Efforts to involve the U.S. armed forces in resolving election disputes would take us into dangerous, unlawful and unconstitutional territory. Civilian and military officials who direct or carry out such measures would be accountable, including potentially facing criminal penalties, for the grave consequences of their actions on our republic.

    Transitions, which all of us have experienced, are a crucial part of the successful transfer of power. They often occur at times of international uncertainty about U.S. national security policy and posture. They can be a moment when the nation is vulnerable to actions by adversaries seeking to take advantage of the situation.

    Given these factors, particularly at a time when U.S. forces are engaged in active operations around the world, it is all the more imperative that the transition at the Defense Department be carried out fully, cooperatively and transparently. Acting defense secretary Christopher C. Miller and his subordinates — political appointees, officers and civil servants — are each bound by oath, law and precedent to facilitate the entry into office of the incoming administration, and to do so wholeheartedly. They must also refrain from any political actions that undermine the results of the election or hinder the success of the new team.

    We call upon them, in the strongest terms, to do as so many generations of Americans have done before them. This final action is in keeping with the highest traditions and professionalism of the U.S. armed forces, and the history of democratic transition in our great country.
  • The Road to 2020 - American Elections
    So, can we blame these losses on Trump?Benkei
    I think so, actually.

    What was predictable was that such an inept leader as Trump would make his last days a total farce and that he would not bother much about what happens to a crucial election to the GOP.

    I would hope that the GOP would break into two. It would be the best thing what could happen to the party, actually. The prevailing stupidity and cynicism of Republican politicians thinking of Trump as a "Kingmaker" is simply mind blowing. Q-anon people are simply lunatics, and it's not a coherent strategy to go with the lunatic fringe. Why people opt for failure is beyond my reasoning. Perhaps they just rely that people forget what happened 6 to 12 months ago or something.

    Of course the biggest reason for Trump's utter failure was his Covid-19 response, in which he failed from the start by going with the Rush Limbaugh line that it was a "common cold" and all was just democratic humbug. And of course, it the pandemic wouldn't have emerged to be a pandemic, but your average "swine-flu scare", that line would have been great. Unfortunately Covid-19 was the real deal, a pandemic. And since Trump is as inept as he is, he couldn't turn around ever from his first reactions.

    I think it would have only taken for Trump closest aides and supporters to portray Trump himself to understand that Covid-19 was his "9/11"-moment, to change policy, be the serious "Crisis-President" and basically win the elections last year. The GOP could have milked the safety issue easily as they did during the 9/11 and following War on Terror era. Only the libertarian fringe would cried about the restrictions, but who cares about them, actually.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)

    And something he pretty much prepared for in 2016. And then totally against his own reasoning and expectations, he actually won the election back then.

    Now he's playing the tune he was so ready and eager to play in 2016, then with that TV program/channel in mind.
  • Cryptocurrency
    Bitcoin's gone up a good bit since this thread was last active, mostly because of institutional hoovering-up of what's available on exchanges. But on a macroscale that might be a bad sign.csalisbury
    This might be so.

    In fact that stocks are going up, gold is going up, bitcoin is going up, all seem to be a sign of one thing:

    Asset price inflantion

    And that may be the result of the Zombification of the economy where huge quantities are put to support financial institutions, large corporations (air lines etc.) and now even consumers.

    Strange times indeed...
  • Coronavirus
    Why that indicator of excess deaths is important as obviously the statistics are just a rough estimate. Yet the differences in the statistics do come up...like this:

    Excess deaths are the difference between the total number of deaths registered and the average over the previous years for the same period. Official figures say 55,827 people have died with Covid-19 in Russia. The deputy prime minister said excess deaths would take that to 186,000. Countries use different methods when reporting deaths related to the virus, which makes international comparisons difficult.

    Russia has been criticised for calculating its official deaths from Covid-19 based on the number of post-mortem examinations that list coronavirus as the main cause of death. However, this means that other deaths linked to Covid-19, which did not list it as the main cause of death, will not have been included.

    The new numbers mean Russia's coronavirus death toll could be the world's third-highest, after the US with 335,000 deaths and Brazil, which has had 192,000, according to a tally by Johns Hopkins University.

    Hence the argument that Covid-19 deaths would be inflated seems at least that in Russia have been deflated. Which would be typical to Soviet Russian authorities.
  • Death of Language - The Real way Cultures Decay and Die?
    When people say Western culture is decaying, they're talking about youths diverging from the incumbent culture, abandoning the things that were thought of as important by the older generation. They're absolutely not talking about an existential crisis like ww3 or a disease which wipes them out. They're talking about reality television or sexual liberation and the like.Judaka
    This is actually one thing I commented earlier as one of the separate discourses in the subject:

    Many likely aren't implying that our culture would end up for archaeologists to dig up and with nobody speaking English, but likely that we lose some crucial parts of our culture. If we don't hold up values that once were important, many will see it as cultural decay.ssu

    And of course, it is those values and norms they hold important. Yet wasn't Sokrates convicted of spoiling the youth? So I guess this idea of youth diverging from the incumbent culture may be older than you think.

    The "collapse of the Roman Empire" was a slow-motion event requiring centuries to be complete.Bitter Crank
    Especially if we consider Eastern Roman Empire as also representing the Roman Empire. Of course it's an interesting question just how Greek were the eastern parts of the Roman Empire right from the start (as the Romans conquered an area dominated by Hellenistic Culture). Byzantine Greek language is still used in liturgy in the Orthodox Church, btw.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump was probably not involved in the painstaking negotiationsNOS4A2
    Well, he probably hasn't been involved in any painstaking negotiations as the President (negotiations with Trump might be painstaking to others).

    At least he takes care of his health by driving a golf cart.

    Gessen-TrumpIndifference.jpg
  • Death of Language - The Real way Cultures Decay and Die?
    You talked about cultural decay but you give examples of people just totally converting to a new culture or genocide.Judaka
    And your problem? Decay is something different from the ordinary evolution and transformation of a culture.

    I think that language is at the heart of your understanding regardless of what anyone else says.Judaka
    What you have said is that 1960's is totally different from today because... I guess you didn't live then.

    To avoid a cultural collapse in Australia we've got to

    1. Call ourselves Australians
    2. Speak English
    3. Be mostly white? If we become 90% ethnically Asian does that still count?
    4. Not let Australia be destroyed or something
    Judaka
    I don't know where people get this obsession with race (and racism). Or you think that Australian culture is inherently white and ethnically Asians cannot nurture/promote/enjoy/advance Australian culture? And with the point of 4. Yes, it might be a good thing not to let happen. Or something.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    Trump listened to Americans instead of his party and administration, and raised a stink about it.NOS4A2
    And shouldn't this be done perhaps well before before an agreement was made, right?

    What would it make you feel if me and you first made an agreement and only after making that agreement I would publicly attack on how baseless and wrong your demands, NOS4A2, are in this proposal and I'm now defending people from the excesses of NOS4A2.

    And I think this is the general pattern how budget deals are made in the US: they aren't done with every one being agreed separately (who would have that time), but in lumps. And of course, when you have lumps, there's always some issue that doesn't sound good, which can then be compared to something very dramatic or deemed important. The classic way is to compare military spending to health care of children and infants. My favorite (from my country) was when people compared the expense that members of parliament use on driving taxis and comparing that huge amount to (fill in the blank) government aid to some benign cause.

    Pandemic relief to Americans compared to nearly anything else is simply 100% pure populism.
  • Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)
    The real villain here is McConnell, not Trump. The Democratic house quickly agreed to Trump’s demands to increase the stimulus check, but of course the Republican senate wouldn’t agree to that.Pfhorrest
    This all just shows the ineptness of Trump. If anyone thinks this is a great way to get "the deal" to made to be done is crazy. This all could have been done without people failing to get the one weeks benefits, it was all ready to be for Trump to be signed before Christmas. Someone else could think that the CEO of the country, the POTUS, would get his own party to back with the 2000$ before during the deal is made prior than an agreement is announced.

    But of course, there's the Trump way of doing things. Now people correct me if I got this wrong (I may have), but it looks like to me like this:

    a) Trump's administration + GOP make a budget deal with the Dems
    b) Trump has to sign this, but he doesn't
    c) Trump makes waves that the budget deal has pork afterwards and wants to raise the benefits, which his party wasn't for.
    d) Trump drags his feet until the government is on the verge of shutdown... to make it more dramatic.
    e) then Trump signs what he had already on b).
    f) in reality, the overall checks are a bit smaller as the payments cannot be done for the past days that Trump dragged his feet. And we'll see if the Senate will go along with Trump's 2000$.

    Art of the deal. Or then I got it wrong and Trump is playing 4D chess!
  • Death of Language - The Real way Cultures Decay and Die?
    By your definition, a culture "declines" by being annihilated, pretty much and really only that.Judaka
    No. That's the most simple, most obvious way where there is hardly any disagreement on what happened. But there are other ways.

    Another thing is simply assimilation. Several conquering people have simply assimilated to the population that they have conquered and their language and beliefs have disappeared. The people might have been excellent horsemen and warriors, but usually the tribal nomad culture etc. is simply no match against a so-called "high-culture" with all the lures and prestige they have.

    Let's take (just as a random example) the Langobards, a Germanic people (possibly from Northern Europe) who ruled most of the Italian Peninsula from 568 to 774. They did have their language, an own religion, a Norse god Vanir that they worshipped, and an own culture. And then they hadn't. They became Christians and basically Romanized before Charlemagne conquered their lands. Hence the language isn't spoken, there's just some artifacts that may possibly be in Langobardic texts. Italian does have words from the Langobardian language (so there's that Cultural heritage) and there is Lombardy in Italy, yet I don't think modern Milanese think of themselves as being Langobards (I don't know any, so maybe I'm wrong).

    And this is what has happened to many cultures that have been victorious on the battlefield and carved up their kingdoms yet have assimilated to the culture they have taken over (and not the other way around): Huns, Vandals and so on.

    Oh but there are these reenactor guys roaming around as langobards! Culture saved?
    dae-vc000510.jpg
  • The role of conspiracy theories in the American right
    Well, with the previous Republican President (Bush the younger), there was one of the greatest conspiracy theories AGAINST the Republicans. And of course conspiracy theories have been part of American political culture since the JFK assassination, at least.

    I think now the reason is simply that you have a POTUS that himself is promoting wild conspiracy theories. And conspiracy buffs like Alex Jones were part of his base. Nothing gets better I guess for conspiracy buffs. Just think of from that point of view: "Well if the President of the US of A himself believes..."

    (And without giving any thought just who this President is.)
  • Death of Language - The Real way Cultures Decay and Die?


    Cultural / Societal / Civilizational collapse could be defined as:

    the fall of a complex human society characterized by the loss of cultural identity and of socioeconomic complexity, the downfall of government, and the rise of violence.

    Notice the "loss of cultural identity". Societies can fall to environmental disasters they cannot cope with, and such genocidal occupations from foreign invaders or mass migrations that the society cannot heal from. Either this can happen dramatically quickly or then it will take a very long time usually by cultural assimilation. The political system, a nation, can quickly collapse, but likely a specific culture doesn't. And I would argue that one of the last things to die is language.

    If so, what are people then talking about cultural decay of our time? Especially about the still quite dominant Western Culture decaying or even collapsing.

    Here I think people have simply another things in mind. There are simply many discourses that people follow when they talk about cultural collapse or cultural decay.

    Many likely aren't implying that our culture would end up for archaeologists to dig up and with nobody speaking English, but likely that we lose some crucial parts of our culture. If we don't hold up values that once were important, many will see it as cultural decay. Decadence as I earlier posted, is seen as one reason. Yet for example Arnold Toynbee believed that there are no laws that explain the phenomenon of the rise and fall of civilizations. Every civilization passes through its own stages and eventually declines after reaching its heights according to Toynbee.

    What then is the decline of a culture? With the language dying away I am talking about a quite literal death, yet likely many will make an argument of decline in some other manner. Of course, this begs the question about what culture is about.
  • Scottish independence
    We could discuss this on a more general level on the status of the autonomy of Scotland versus a sovereign state.

    The Scottish Parliament can decide on matters as:

    agriculture, forestry and fisheries
    education and training
    environment
    health and social services
    housing
    law and order
    local government
    sport and the arts
    tourism and economic development
    many aspects of transport

    While the UK Parliament is responsible for matters like:

    benefits and social security
    immigration
    defence
    foreign policy
    employment
    broadcasting
    trade and industry
    nuclear energy, oil, coal, gas and electricity
    consumer rights
    data protection
    the Constitution

    And looking at the list, while "health and social services" and also "law and order" are under Scottish Paliament rule, I would assume that the Scottish Parliament / Scottish leadership can decide on issues concerning a pandemic. Hence the actions of Nicola Sturgeon seem from my point of view be totally in line with Scottish autonomy.
  • Scottish independence
    In a similar way here the Capital region and Southern Finland was closed for a while from the rest of Finland. The Police and also the Armed Forces were deployed to oversee any traffic. Doesn't mean that there's a border between Southern Finland and the rest of Finland.

    230d171c4abd710c7f1bd4a04adc3cfd_XL.jpg
  • Brexit
    Not sure about the figures re shifting assets though.Tim3003
    I would think similar. I assume that it gives just a figure in the ballpark of the amount of assets now transferred to be managed under EU jurisdiction. London was such a convenient place for asset management, you know. Likely it's about portfolio's of institutional or private investors. You see, a hedge fund has still to have a home place.
  • Death of Language - The Real way Cultures Decay and Die?

    Yes. The importance of language is obvious in that anthropology, the study of human societies and cultures and their development, has as one of it's main fields linguistic anthropology:

    c970d6a01b60bd8386f845a5953f76c2.jpg

    There are periods of decline and then periods reform and renaissance.frank

    To note that renaissances can happen is important as it's not obviously only a story of a culture emerging, enjoying it's apogee, decaying and then dying out and having only remnants in museums and possibly giving cultural heritage to newer cultures. That breaks the doom & gloom attitude towards existing cultures.
  • Brexit
    What was up with the fish? I gather the image of a sovereign nation with deep historical links to the sea and to the times when territory was most important. Fishing is a rather small venue for the British economy.

    Well, at least Dublin, Frankfurt and other smaller financial centers are very happy about Brexit, if we look for those who are the winners.

    From 1st of October this year:

    Financial services firms operating in the U.K. have shifted about 7,500 employees and more than 1.2 trillion pounds ($1.6 trillion) of assets to the European Union ahead of Brexit -- with more likely to follow in coming weeks, according to EY.

    About 400 relocations were announced in the past month alone, the consulting firm said in a report on Thursday that tracks 222 of the largest financial firms with significant operations in the U.K. Since Britain voted to leave the bloc in 2016, the finance industry has added 2,850 positions in the EU, with Dublin, Luxembourg and Frankfurt seeing the biggest gains.

    That's something like 1/10 of the assets managed in the City of London. Wonder how that impacts the economy of greater London.

    20180329_Brexit_Bankers.jpg
  • Scottish independence
    Yes, a picture from a Hollywood blockbuster film with an American actor with ties to Australia obviously makes the point. At least the film was filmed PARTLY in Scotland. :roll:
  • Scottish independence
    Can the Scots legally control their own borders? (I recognize my question may have built-in ignorance.)tim wood
    More like built-in contempt for the Scots. Because today they don't have any border to England as they are part of the UK.

    However,

    Scotland has been an independent country for a long time in history. It has institutions and infrastructure that are at par with others West European countries. Needless to say that they (the Scotts) are totally capable of handling every area of independence and perfectly capable of handling an independent Scotland as a sovereign state. And likely they would get into the EU quite easily after already having been there. The only nut to crack would be their southern neighbor, which wouldn't like it. The border with Ireland and Northern Ireland gives people a hint of the future problems if Scotland opts for independence.

    Interesting to see how the English handle Scottish independence movement now. Or then the Scottish Independence Party fucks up it again. Because the UK government is smart enough not to be a bully and send Challenger tanks to roam the streets of Edinburgh. I would think that London's hope is just to drag it's feet, not to give coverage to the topic and hope the economy recovers so much that people are OK with their present union.

    No independence for them in 2014:
    _77701383_77701382.jpg

    Or then things go to the worse and you won't have the issue solved with polite political dialogue and peaceful elections, but with far dismal outcomes, which actually is the norm for humanity.

    Interesting to see what happens to Northern Ireland also.
  • Is anxiety at the centre of agricultural society?
    . It seems likely that people gradually drifted into settled agriculture because there were some advantages to that kind of lifestyle, compared to exclusive hunting and gathering.Bitter Crank
    Or simply there wasn't enough wildlife to hunt. Hunter gatherers simply have to be few, while agriculture can support far larger populations. And of course the domestication of sheep, pigs and cattle happened only some couple thousand years later than agriculture (8 000 BC or so). Once you start "farming" animals, not so much need for wild game.