Comments

  • why does socrates reject property dualist concept of mind
    Thank you everyone. This has helped me. It is very difficult for us when we basically get 12 hours of lecture on the apology, logic and the forms and then have to grasp this on our own. Many of us never had a simple philosophy course either. Thank you. Doing some more reading on the points you all have raised.
  • why does socrates reject property dualist concept of mind
    Those terms are just in the prompt of the question. I believe that is the heart of my confusion. I dont know if they are suggesting "property dualist" is dualism or something else. Why does Socrates then reject the harmony view?
  • why does socrates reject property dualist concept of mind
    I would think this is in reference to the objections to the immortality of the soul by the interlocutors per the argument of the harmony and the lyre and Socrates subsequent rejection thereof, but I am confused with respect to the details of his rejection.
  • why does socrates reject property dualist concept of mind
    We have studied and discussed the Phaedo
  • why does socrates reject property dualist concept of mind
    This is the complete question. I am in theological formation and we were posed multiple questions.
    None were problematic except this one:
    Considering the “soul as a harmony view” in what ways does this consider an “emergent property” or “property dualist” conception of mind, and why does Socrates reject this view?