The Global Economy: What Next? ? ? ?
How is it fundamentally flawed?
You think that speculative bubbles happen in times when interest rates are high and banks don't lend or what? Tell me an example of a speculative bubble happening in that kind of environment.
And tell me of a speculative bubble that didn't have speculation?? — ssu
Because I think we need to distinguish between speculation and investing. If investors
en masse invest because of cheap credit, this has nothing to do with speculation. I think the distinction between an economic bubble and a speculative bubble is useful; a speculative bubble can exist in a specific asset class but speculators as distinct from investors are a much smaller group that don't have the influence to cause economic bubbles.
Simply because prices don't reflect underlying value, this doesn't mean it is caused by speculation but there's a tendency to call it a speculative bubble regardless of cause. The stupidity of the name even resulted in idiotic measures like banning short selling. This resulted in an even bigger downward trend in the markets, because it wasn't speculators causing it but investors who now had to outright sell their positions to manage their risks.
Obviously, my comment about interest rates and monetary policy concerns the
current asset inflation. The previous one was driven by inflated real estate prices, combined with bad loan origination and complex derivatives. No speculation involved, again. Just stupidity in the loan origination part with bad incentives all over the place and moronic optimism about always upward moving "markets".
Pursuit of price stability? I don't understand where this is coming from. Please explain. — ssu
Central Banks have a limited range of measures at their disposal because they're constrained by their purpose of maintaining price stability. Which is a quaint left over from the days when they thought price stability would avoid the boom and bust cycle and unreasonable fear of deflation. So they can basically only regulate the money supply and interest rate. And here we are.
There's of course a lot else going on. Like the fact people will save regardless of interest rates because they have saving goals. So all these theories can't deal with the complexity of human action and there's always unintended consequences and effects. It's time we stop basing policy on necessarily flawed theory.