So to continue the figure of speech, the "camera" started with film and then added the chassis, lens, etc. — Bitter Crank
I don't know. DNA, and proximity to same and other cell types seems to be part of how cells organize themselves into tissues and organs. But then, one step back, why did DNA and the cells begin self-organizing in the first place? — Bitter Crank
an apple seed, and the apple, can occupy the same place at the same time.
— Don Wade — Pop
What you have stated here is not logical. Two things cannot occupy the same space at the same time. because if they did then they would be the same thing. Whilst a seed is within an apple, an apple is not within a seed. An apple does not occupy the same space as the seed. It occupies more space then the seed. I think your point needs rephrasing. — Pop
I think its because self organization is the nature of our universe. — Pop
Yeah, in minor evolutionary increments, such as to give the impression of determinism with a small amount of randomness causing variation. — Pop
But given the vast amount of time that short-lived organisms have had to develop, the deterministic rule might be "If it 'works' it stays." — Bitter Crank
I find a lot of credence in your assertion — Bitter Crank
Thanks again for your response! Then let's look at the question: "When is an apple seed an apple seed?" I believe that while the seed is still in the apple it is still a seed. (Even though it is also part of the apple, at the same time.) The seed doesn't need to be visible in order to exist. If we say the seed only exists when it's not in the apple would deny the seeds existence almost all the time. Apple seeds exist as does other masses. The problem is in our traditional way of perceiving the seed (in our mind) - not in the existence of the seed. — Don Wade
Sorry, but I'm not really following you. I accept that the seed and apple are enmeshed conceptually. But the logic of the enmeshment is quite clear. The relationship of the elements cause the whole - in this case an apple. — Pop
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.