:ok:Perhaps, He was experiencing the Father within Him. Most scholars think that this verse together with others is an indication that God is trion. — MoK
Going back to the OP, I wonder if the saying was a metaphor for depicting the absurdity in life on earth.He said on the Cross: "My God, My God, Why Have You Forsaken Me?". How could He be abandoned if He and God are one? — MoK
I think all Christians believe that this verse is not a metaphor. They believe that Jesus died on the Cross and rose from death. This verse together with other verses is paradoxical though.Going back to the OP, I wonder if the saying was a metaphor for depicting the absurdity in life on earth. — Corvus
I am not sure who all the Christians are. And are all the Christians same in their beliefs? Are all the Christians the genuine Christians? There might be folks who claim to be the Christians but turn out to be some business minded folks trying to make money off the followers. Who knows? Are you a Christian yourself? What do you feel about this point?I think all Christians believe that this verse is not a metaphor. — MoK
Do you believe it?They believe that Jesus died on the Cross and rose from death. — MoK
Paradoxical is used for the puzzles or linguistic problems which have no rational explanation for its contradiction. For example, this sentence is false. It is true if it is false, and false if it is true.This verse together with other verses is paradoxical though. — MoK
There are different branches of Christianity.I am not sure who all the Christians are. And are all the Christians same in their beliefs? — Corvus
There are genuine Christians.Are all the Christians the genuine Christians? — Corvus
Maybe.There might be folks who claim to be the Christians but turn out to be some business minded folks trying to make money off the followers. — Corvus
I am not.Are you a Christian yourself? — Corvus
Of course not. How could I believe something contrary?Do you believe it? — Corvus
God/Jesus cannot be both changeless and changeable simultaneously. Even if we accept that He cannot change His nature and become changeable only (Malachi 3:6 I am the Lord, I change not...). — MoK
Does the following explanation involve a change in God/Jesus' nature, yes or no?
Jesus has both natures: an ordinary, human nature, and an extra-ordinary nature, a divine nature. When Jesus undergoes kenosis (an extra-ordinary process) at crucifixion, he renounces his divine nature, and retains only his human nature. — Arcane Sandwich — Arcane Sandwich
I already answered that. It is contrary that God/Jesus is changeable and changeless simultaneously. Even if we accept this, according to the Bible God does not change so Jesus could not lose His divine nature. Therefore Kenosisism is wrong. — MoK
God cannot change therefore Jesus is not God.So Jesus can't walk from here to there, just like you and me, for example? He doesn't undergo change of location? — Arcane Sandwich
So Jesus can't walk from here to there, just like you and me, for example? He doesn't undergo change of location? — Arcane Sandwich
God cannot change therefore Jesus is not God. — MoK
He said on the Cross: "My God, My God, Why Have You Forsaken Me?". How could He be abandoned if He and God are one? — MoK
Jesus as human cannot be God because He is subject to change.Is Jesus God? — Arcane Sandwich
He said on the Cross: "My God, My God, Why Have You Forsaken Me?". How could He be abandoned if He and God are one? — MoK
I could not believe something contrary. I believe in all sorts of different things that I am not certain about but none of them are the contrary.Many things in life is contrary, but people believe them. — Corvus
Of course, I won't believe something contrary.Being contrary doesn't mean that you cannot believe it. — Corvus
I don't think so. I think that question refers to a state of being abandoned by God.The saying in the quote is not a statement. It is in the form of question. He is asking questions. There is no truth or falsity in the question at all. He is asking someone to give him the answers for his question. It would be only true or false, if he said, " My God, You forsaken me." — Corvus
What do you mean by making into God? — MoK
So He was not God when He was human?Many folks believe he is God. He doesn't seem to have had been God when he was alive. He was just an ordinary bloke. — Corvus
Now you are saying that He resurrected and He was God.But when he dies on the cross, and resurrected he became God. Ordinary folks don't resurrect after death. Only God can resurrect. — Corvus
Don't you see any contradiction in your conclusion? — MoK
How do you know that He became God after the resurrection?It is not a conclusion. It is an inference.
It is perfectly reasonable inference, if you read any Hegel and knew about Dialectical Logic.
From daily life, it can be also reasoned. Things don't stay as they are. All things change with time and events in the world. — Corvus
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.