The Subjects of Reality
What is the nature of the mind, inasmuch as that means the capacity for believing and making such judgements about what to believe? — Pfhorrest
The Institutes of Knowledge
What is the proper educational system, or who should be making those descriptive judgements and how should they relate to each other and others, socially speaking? — Pfhorrest
Bonus question: How do we get people to care about education and knowledge and reality to begin with? — Pfhorrest
The Importance of Knowledge
Why does it matter what is real or not, true or false, in the first place? — Pfhorrest
That sound like an answer to my question about the meaning of descriptive statement, — Pfhorrest
A thought is a perception of a feeling coupled with a desire for that feeling to remain... — Pfhorrest
A thought is a perception of a feeling coupled with a desire for that feeling to remain, or else whatever feeling is desired in its stead: basically, a thought is what you feel you ought to feel, the mental states you judge to be the correct ones. — Pfhorrest
The Objects of Reality
What are the criteria by which to judge descriptive claims, or what is it that makes something real? — Pfhorrest
Why do you claim reflexive mental activity requires naming or other linguistic capability? — Pfhorrest
I described thought as reflexive mental activity. If that wasn’t clear then I think you’re not understanding anything I’ve said. — Pfhorrest
What you have yet to have done is offer a bare minimum criterion for what counts as thought and belief. Such a standard/criterion is the device we use to determine whether or not some situation counts as a case of thought and belief. — creativesoul
But do we really use some device to understand 'thought' or 'belief' in ordinary language? — Eee
What if an investigation of thought leads to the conclusion that no device constructed by this or that philosopher can ever get it just right? — Eee
After all, any investigation of the notions of thought or belief must already use these words and their naive meanings. We use the supposedly broken thing in order to fix it, proving that it wasn't so broken.
Yeah... ...you haven't told me what you think either of them consist of... — Pfhorrest
Why quote the terms? — creativesoul
I'm using those two terms as a namesake for the same referent. That referent is prior to language. That referent is an integral element within all thought and belief, those existentially dependent upon language use notwithstanding. — creativesoul
"God did it" doesn't work any more than "Aliens did it" any more than "The Flying Spaghetti Monster" did it... — creativesoul
What we need is knowledge of what all thought and belief consists of. — creativesoul
Then, and only then, can we determine what the particular thought belief is about. — creativesoul
All thought and belief consists of mental correlations drawn between different things. — creativesoul
My criterion for "just right" includes a basis borne of universal criteria. — creativesoul
I quote the words that we already know how to use. — Eee
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.