Whatever merit that argument has in pointing out what is in each of our control or not, it has no room to distinguish different ways to be a parent or promote institutions that build up those new people. Standing outside of those concerns is its own kind of irresponsibility. If the most important matter becomes proving that all reproduction is ultimately guilty of inflicting risk to future generations, it cannot be important that one family nourishes what another spoils or that education builds up or breaks down persons.
And those issues are what is important to those who bring new people into the world. — Valentinus
Should that be ultimately decided by those human beings agreeing to a moral code where the cessation is required? — Valentinus
How is that less authoritarian than whatever you oppose? — Valentinus
I understand that your argument is an appeal to voluntary acceptance of a condition or truth about a condition. — Valentinus
But the idea of responsibility is based upon what people should do or not. It is authoritative by default, for better and worse. — Valentinus
you seem to be saying that utopia will never be achieved in the future because it has not already been achieved — Alvin Capello
Without the power to change behavior, the whole idea is a dream. — Valentinus
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.