Throng
On your view, when we look out into the yard at the red oak, do we see a tree or our perception of the tree? I'm just curious.
— creativesoul
I find that question confusing. You can't see a perception. "Seeing a tree" is perception. Visual perception. That involves a lot of things and includes stuff that happens quite a bit away from your body, such as light travelling from the tree to your retina. So from the light hitting the tree to our brain processing nerve signals we have a dynamic system. — Dawnstorm
I'm fine saying we see a tree, but I'm unsure we attach the same meaning to that clause. — Dawnstorm
Saying we see the perception of a tree feels like a meta-level transgression. — Dawnstorm
Since the terms here are... tricky and I don't need to phrase that to myself I'm not confident I can fully explain. Maybe like this? I believe there's a thing out there that becomes an object when a subject faces it. So when we both see the same tree we see the same thing but not the same object. And treeness is part of the object rather than the thing, but the thing restricts what qualities can attach to the object. Sorry if this is confusing, but I don't think there's an easy way to phrase this.
I certainly can't answer your question with a multiple-choice tick. — Dawnstorm
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.