The position of the agnostic as written in the proposition is the only position an agnostic can't claim or assert. — god must be atheist
If I am agnostic, I claim no knowledge of god. But god would certainly have knowledge of god. So to claim that an agnostic thinks he or she is god while he claims no knowledge of god despite being god himself or herself is the stupidest conclusion anyone could draw. — god must be atheist
180 Proof
827
What do you mean by "wrong?" Please define it.
— Frank Apisa
This is what's wrong with it. Read for comprehension, Frank, as many time as it takes for you to get the gist. A hint: what is wrong is that you have not defined the gods - classes or particular ones - that you claim not know whether or not they exist; saying "all gods" says nothing definite.
For example, I'm agnostic about a class, or concept, of divinity termed 'pandeism' and another 'animism' which are conventionally defined; on the other hand, I believe - as you insist that I have a belief - that the 'negation of theism' (also defined) is true, which makes me an anti-theist and only by implication also an atheist.
I provide the above link again to a prior post where I argued that what is wrong with your alleged "agnosticism" is that it's incoherent because your use of "gods" is wholly undefined. — 180 Proof
Nonsense (or in your crotchety parlance - "bullshit"!) Not. Even. False.What do you mean by the word "wrong?" — Frank Apisa
180 Proof
829
What do you mean by the word "wrong?"
— Frank Apisa
Nonsense (or in your crotchety parlance - "bullshit"!) Not. Even. False. — 180 Proof
180 Proof
833
↪Frank Apisa Stop trolling. — 180 Proof
This is what's wrong with it. Read for comprehension, Frank, as many time as it takes for you to get the gist. — 180 Proof
LOL, welcome to the fan club. Trying to argue with the guy is like banging your head against the wall... he simply does not comprehend what is being said and goes back to his one single line about atheism, which he never tires of repeating. — Nobeernolife
Yeah. All Frankie's got is trollin' ... and some of us are bored enough to play whack-a-troll with him. What a hypocrite though: he allows himself to define "atheism" in a self-serving manner but does not allow anyone else to define "agnosticism" - even for the sake of discussion - in any way other than the way he does. And then he wonders why he's the piñata du jour. :yawn:LOL, welcome to the fan club. Trying to argue with the guy is like banging your head against the wall... — Nobeernolife
LOL, welcome to the fan club. Trying to argue with the guy is like banging your head against the wall...
— Nobeernolife
Yeah. All Frankie's got is trollin' ... and some of us are bored enough to play whack-a-troll with him. — 180 Proof
180 Proof
839
LOL, welcome to the fan club. Trying to argue with the guy is like banging your head against the wall...
— Nobeernolife
Yeah. All Frankie's got is trollin' ... and some of us are bored enough to play whack-a-troll with him. What a hypocrite though: he allows himself to define "atheism" in a self-serving manner but does not allows anyone else to define "agnosticism" - even for the sake of discussion - in any way other than the way he does. And then he wonders why he's the piñata du jour. :yawn: — 180 Proof
god must be atheist
2k
LOL, welcome to the fan club. Trying to argue with the guy is like banging your head against the wall...
— Nobeernolife
Yeah. All Frankie's got is trollin' ... and some of us are bored enough to play whack-a-troll with him.
— 180 Proof
When you show him black-on-white, quoting him, that he is wrong, he will call you an asshole and go on with his own beloved self-created stickhorse. His stick-horse, however, is a one-trick pony and we have seen all it could perform, over and over and over again.
I used to know a guy in a social setting back twenty-thirty years ago who very vehemently had some views on the relationship between intellect and literacy; and he proposed it in a very aggressive and provocative way; it always incited someone in the company to respond and argue with him, but that's all he did. He was otherwise a kind, friendly, helpful sort of feller, he was not jealous, greedy, defiant, or unreasonable otherwise. — god must be atheist
It applies to you also. — Frank Apisa
Yeah. All Frankie's got is trollin' ... and some of us are bored enough to play whack-a-troll with him. What a hypocrite though: he allows himself to define "atheism" in a self-serving manner but does not allows anyone else to define "agnosticism" - even for the sake of discussion - in any way other than the way he does. And then he wonders why he's the piñata du jour. :yawn: — 180 Proof
180 Proof
841
↪Frank Apisa Troll is as troll does ... :mask: — 180 Proof
god must be atheist
2k
It applies to you also.
— Frank Apisa
You're in over your head in this, Frank. When you are reduced to comebacks that lose their effectiveness past grade three, you know you have run your course and out of ammunition. Time for you to migrate to Philosophynow.org. — god must be atheist
Nobeernolife
341
Yeah. All Frankie's got is trollin' ... and some of us are bored enough to play whack-a-troll with him. What a hypocrite though: he allows himself to define "atheism" in a self-serving manner but does not allows anyone else to define "agnosticism" - even for the sake of discussion - in any way other than the way he does. And then he wonders why he's the piñata du jour. :yawn:
— 180 Proof
Oh, he is a well-known troll around here? I had sort of written it off as senility. Either way, I plonk him, but if it is not Alzheimers I scrap the sympathy too. — Nobeernolife
If you could logically show any of my arguments — Frank Apisa
Nobeernolife
343
If you could logically show any of my arguments
— Frank Apisa
There was no argument, let alone several. Now go away, troll. — Nobeernolife
Antidote
137
Hi Frank, still at it I see. I found this in the bible this morning and thought it might be helpful...
"If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God." — Antidote
"If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God." — Antidote
If it's not helpful, by all means ignore it. — Antidote
So what are the things that define your concept of "God"? — Pfhorrest
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.