I am not sure how to make a conclusive argument here, but the whole position looks more shaky - the presence of a piece of paper with some letters on it ought not to bring truth into a world. — Pneumenon
The problem is this cannot be a truth about the world without minds by definition. — m-theory
You can't make mind dependent claims about the truth of worlds if truth is mind dependent. — m-theory
So it is not a truth about the world, that truth is mind dependent. — m-theory
P = Truth is mind dependent
`P = The world is absent of minds — m-theory
So to say that truth is mind dependent is true means that it cannot be a truth in a world absent of minds.
So where there are no minds there are no truths.
But this is a contradiction.
In the absence of mind/truth, it is not true that there are no truths without contradiction. — m-theory
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.