TranscendedRealms
I like sushi
If this is too much material for you to read, then just read what you're willing to. When reading and responding to this, do so from the very beginning. I explain why I think good, bad, beauty, horror, tragedy, etc. can only be emotions (feelings/perceptions/value judgments). — TranscendedRealms
A Seagull
I explain why I think good, bad, beauty, horror, tragedy, etc. can only be emotions — TranscendedRealms
Syamsu
TranscendedRealms
TranscendedRealms
Sam26
TranscendedRealms
Sam26
TranscendedRealms
Sam26
TranscendedRealms
Heiko
Good and bad are nothing more than value judgments, and value judgments are actual things. They're emotions. — TranscendedRealms
Sam26
TranscendedRealms
Heiko
The direkt link to emotion maybe original. But we live in modern times. The objective meaning has to reproduce itself in a much more abstract way over different media.I didn't understand what you said. Could you clarify? — TranscendedRealms
Sam26
Andrew4Handel
I like sushi
Possibility
Isaac
It would seem to me to be a sad thing if people just pursued those things that made them feel good. — Sam26
Sam26
So what would guide people's behaviour if not making them feel good, doing what's right? — Isaac
Isaac
It may not feel good to jump into ice cold water to save another person's life, but you do it in spite of how it makes you feel. — Sam26
unenlightened
Are you suggesting that someone who just jumped into ice cold water to save another person's life mightn't feel at all good about themselves? — Isaac
Isaac
I think he's suggesting they'd feel rather cold. — unenlightened
ztaziz
unenlightened
We should instead see it as a good or beautiful thing he gets locked up in prison. Or, we could see it as a good or beautiful thing that he's torturing those living things. Either way, we're getting beauty and goodness out of it. — TranscendedRealms
unenlightened
Hence the example does not demonstrate that "doing the right thing has nothing to do with how you feel". — Isaac
Get involved in philosophical discussions about knowledge, truth, language, consciousness, science, politics, religion, logic and mathematics, art, history, and lots more. No ads, no clutter, and very little agreement — just fascinating conversations.