So, God should exist to satisfy your cause-effect mental scheme, — Angelo Cannata

The universe is made from non-intelligent dead basic material — Hillary

But how did it create itself? — Hillary

There was no creation. — Jackson

How do you know? — Hillary

Im no Christian. I dont believe in God. — Hillary

How do you know there was? — Jackson

How you know there wasn't? Scientific dogma tells you that. — Hillary

That's nice. — Jackson

What science says the world always existed? — Jackson

Then it still needs a reason it exists. — Hillary

If the universe always existed then why does it need a reason? — Jackson

There might not be a first cause, but there just has to be a reason for life. — Hillary

Why does there have to be a reason? — Jackson

And non-intelligent particles — Hillary

Yes, and this I contest. — Jackson

What intelligence has a particle? How it creates itself out of the blue, even if eternal? — Hillary

The why question doesn't apply to the existence of gods, as eternal intelligences don't require another reason. — Hillary

Is my argument sound? Can we say it's a proof even?

So the universe exists without a reason? All life exists without a reason? — Hillary

NB: The only "reason for existence" that does not beg the question (i.e. an infinite regress) – that is rational – is that there is no reason for existence. — 180 Proof

Why is there no reason? — Hillary

Performative contradiction. — 180 Proof

How can dead stuff, out of which life evolved, just exist, even eternally, without a cause, or better, a reason for its existence? Letting it pop into existence by some "mindless spark", like brother — Hillary